in my group Discipline just comes through mutual respect for people. If you respect me,I respect you right?
If someone is a terrible leader in my group (and I am merely meaning the tactics on field or so) Then we all say "thanks a lot" insert name... have a good laugh, and move on...
that is what separates units where you get a good laugh a enjoyable time from the ones where you would have to address your "superiors" with "sir yes sir"
The biggest mistake is to actually try to portray the behavior that a real military drill style environment expects from you. who want to be disciplined the entire time or punished by some guy that calls himself a captain on the internet and seen the drill instructor scene from full metal jacket a bit too much.. If you start giving out punishments then that will be the actual cause for mutually assured disrespect and eventually conflicts. Its a gaming environment... we are not dealing with dogs that get a cookie after they done good or a slap on the nose if they done bad (well hold that last thought i guess lol)
I like to say in our group we have somewhat of a realistic setup. But at the beginning and end of the day I am just that same guy as the guy that has that Private tag. And if that Privates wants to lead for a round or map he can do so and he should be getting the chance to do so. Really that little tag that we all put in front of our name to say what rank we are its BS really... its all eye candy making your group look nice and organized etc...nothing more nothing less. Whenever people are starting to take it a bit to serious that is where they tend to go over the top and ruin it for others.
Punishment and reinforcement process applied to behavioral analysis? really? boy are you in for a treat the FSE community has people with the best social and behavioral skills...