NWL - League 2 [Post results here!]

[John Price]

That rule in my opinion is the most under enforced. The amount of times you see regiments run away from shots with 5 man spacing etc. or making 4 man spacing on the move is insane.

At the same time though who cares. If they have big gaps on the move and you don't, you form up quicker.

[DasBrot]

That rule in my opinion is the most under enforced. The amount of times you see regiments run away from shots with 5 man spacing etc. or making 4 man spacing on the move is insane.

At the same time though who cares. If they have big gaps on the move and you don't, you form up quicker.

Thats most likely because its a new rule and not easy to enforce. I too struggle at that one. Then, a referees view and opinion might differ from that of an officer the most in that one.

1b.1 A formation is a tight line, with gaps tightly closed when standing, and with gaps not bigger than 2 men average while moving.
 
Is this rule still working?

And yes, of course it is still in use.

[wilu_daskar]

And yes, of course it is still in use.

Thanks for answer.

I will ask to compare the following:

Good line (have copied this from the DasBrot message in the main thread)

Spoiler

[close]

Rulebraking line (same)

Spoiler

[close]

Lines we have in last NWL match vs 44th (sorry for bug with austrian uniforms - some graphic modifications )

Spoiler

[close]

What could you say about lines in the 3rd screenshot?

[Toffee]

Maybe a good idea would be to have a council of referees to vote on any disputed decision. As long as a team provides video evidence of what happened and the refs come to a majority the game or round could be replayed at a later date.

[Wolfster]

Spoiler

And yes, of course it is still in use.

Thanks for answer.

I will ask to compare the following:

Good line (have copied this from the DasBrot message in the main thread)

Spoiler

[close]

Rulebraking line (same)

Spoiler

[close]

Lines we have in last NWL match vs 44th (sorry for bug with austrian uniforms - some graphic modifications )

Spoiler

[close]

What could you say about lines in the 3rd screenshot?

[close]

As you can see, for the most part, our line was close together. It isn't particularly easy keeping the spacings equal if you are reversing every 10 seconds. You shouldn't just be blaming it on us. You were doing the same thing.



If you really want to get me started, I can mention the invites you had. But I thought I'd respect you guys by letting it slip.

[DasBrot]

And yes, of course it is still in use.

Thanks for answer.

I will ask to compare the following:

Good line (have copied this from the DasBrot message in the main thread)

Spoiler

[close]

Rulebraking line (same)

Spoiler

[close]

Lines we have in last NWL match vs 44th (sorry for bug with austrian uniforms - some graphic modifications )

Spoiler

[close]

What could you say about lines in the 3rd screenshot?

In the screenshot, the front part is good, the rear part is not good. As a referee, I would remind them of the rule but nothing more.

[wilu_daskar]

In the screenshot, the front part is good, the rear part is not good. As a referee, I would remind them of the rule but nothing more.

Thanks for answer. And if this happens again and again?

[bruno73]

gg 5-5 against 61e. Some fic but it didn't troubled rounds issues

[huanmpth]

gg 5-5 against 61e. Some fic but it didn't troubled rounds issues

Good job but lost need more experience in my opinion.

[Wolfster]

44th 7 - 3 Saints

Good job I'd focus on camping less - might prove you better.

[Wüstenfuchs]

33rd 5 - 5 44th

good game, nearly no rulebreaks apart from one little FiC of each side

[Munj]

Maybe a good idea would be to have a council of referees to vote on any disputed decision. As long as a team provides video evidence of what happened and the refs come to a majority the game or round could be replayed at a later date.

Too impractical, time consuming and generally inefficient. Also getting matches done is hard enough as it is, let alone replaying rounds over retrospective discussion. They don't do this in sports (e.g. Football) because it just wouldn't be conducive to fluid play.

[Wolfster]

And add a camping timer -_- xD

[bruno73]

And add a camping timer -_- xD

There was a rule in last editions which restricted the camp time under than 5 minutes. Also, there was like 7 or 10 volleys maximum to don't favorise the camp.

[Wolfster]

And add a camping timer -_- xD

There was a rule in last editions which restricted the camp time under than 5 minutes. Also, there was like 7 or 10 volleys maximum to don't favorise the camp.

That rule should come back