| NWBC | Season 5 | Finals

[Scottish Unicorn]

That's a dumb idea.

Thank you for the insightful wisdom Mr Unicorn. Care to actually elaborate on what makes it bad in your eyes so we can theorise a better way?

No.

[Vegi.]

That's a dumb idea.

Thank you for the insightful wisdom Mr Unicorn. Care to actually elaborate on what makes it bad in your eyes so we can theorise a better way?

No.

Didnt ask

[Enderby]

To be honest with regards to Arty, a vote was done but wasn't done with all the signed up teams? We were never included in the vote unless one of my guys has gone rogue

cav shouldn't dismount during all charge, as simple as that

I can't agree with this at all. Even dismounted a cav player is at a large advantage to an infantry player, especially in a more casual environment.

With all due respect, you didn't play much cavalry to say that, a cavalryman doesn't stand a chance in 1v1 mounted against a bayonet, he'll be dismounted and killed instantly thanks to his range, take my word for it 

We can also find rules to reduce the advantage of the infantry too, it's just stupid, like i said :

"Adding rules just because peoples have trouble facing hussars is like adding rules to the infentry because the hussars have trouble facing the infantry, it's just a problem of skill personal, for example, I had a hard time killing infantry, i suck, the difficulty is the same for both, a hussar can die suddenly, the infantry too, everyone has their strengths and weaknesses, I think everyone agrees with that. To add penalties is to misunderstand the classes"

RIP The Arty

[John Price]

To be honest with regards to Arty, a vote was done but wasn't done with all the signed up teams? We were never included in the vote unless one of my guys has gone rogue

cav shouldn't dismount during all charge, as simple as that

I can't agree with this at all. Even dismounted a cav player is at a large advantage to an infantry player, especially in a more casual environment.

With all due respect, you didn't play much cavalry to say that, a cavalryman doesn't stand a chance in 1v1 mounted against a bayonet, he'll be dismounted and killed instantly thanks to his range, take my word for it 

I played and lead cavalry long before I made my own infantry regiment so thats not quite true  We are talking about the All Charge only here. I am well aware who has what advantage in a 1v1 between an Infantry player and a cav player.

With respect to you, because I also have no clue who you are, there is a reason why having cav dismount etc. became a thing. Its not just out of a hatred from infantry players. When the all charge is called and cohesion is lost, the point is for it to be an equal playing field for everyone left to the best of the admins ability. So that everyone gets a chance providing you are not dead already. Thats not the only reason, but honestly its the only reason needed.

If we were to have a season without all-charge, it would be shit.

[Enderby]

To be honest with regards to Arty, a vote was done but wasn't done with all the signed up teams? We were never included in the vote unless one of my guys has gone rogue

cav shouldn't dismount during all charge, as simple as that

I can't agree with this at all. Even dismounted a cav player is at a large advantage to an infantry player, especially in a more casual environment.

With all due respect, you didn't play much cavalry to say that, a cavalryman doesn't stand a chance in 1v1 mounted against a bayonet, he'll be dismounted and killed instantly thanks to his range, take my word for it 

I played and lead cavalry long before I made my own infantry regiment so thats not quite true  We are talking about the All Charge only here. I am well aware who has what advantage in a 1v1 between an Infantry player and a cav player.

With respect to you, because I also have no clue who you are, there is a reason why having cav dismount etc. became a thing. Its not just out of a hatred from infantry players. When the all charge is called and cohesion is lost, the point is for it to be an equal playing field for everyone left to the best of the admins ability. So that everyone gets a chance providing you are not dead already. Thats not the only reason, but honestly its the only reason needed.

If we were to have a season without all-charge, it would be shit.

Oh you don't know me when you played cav? Hello, Enderby the jumper of the 4e Huss winner of 4 cavalry tournament, league 1 with the 4e Huss, Strange never to have met him if you have already played cav

I see, so go to play all inf, this is a GF now, not a event after this there are several classes, you have to accept it, the advantages as well as the disadvantages. You forgot the very principle of the game: Napoleonic wars.

[Saitama]

Tbh we should just give the cav players admin horses since they seem to be disabled in general disadvantaged on foot

[John Price]

To be honest with regards to Arty, a vote was done but wasn't done with all the signed up teams? We were never included in the vote unless one of my guys has gone rogue

cav shouldn't dismount during all charge, as simple as that

I can't agree with this at all. Even dismounted a cav player is at a large advantage to an infantry player, especially in a more casual environment.

With all due respect, you didn't play much cavalry to say that, a cavalryman doesn't stand a chance in 1v1 mounted against a bayonet, he'll be dismounted and killed instantly thanks to his range, take my word for it 

I played and lead cavalry long before I made my own infantry regiment so thats not quite true  We are talking about the All Charge only here. I am well aware who has what advantage in a 1v1 between an Infantry player and a cav player.

With respect to you, because I also have no clue who you are, there is a reason why having cav dismount etc. became a thing. Its not just out of a hatred from infantry players. When the all charge is called and cohesion is lost, the point is for it to be an equal playing field for everyone left to the best of the admins ability. So that everyone gets a chance providing you are not dead already. Thats not the only reason, but honestly its the only reason needed.

If we were to have a season without all-charge, it would be shit.

I see, so go to play all inf, this is a GF now, not a event after this there are several classes, you have to accept it, the advantages as well as the disadvantages. You forgot the very principle of the game: Napoleonic wars.

Yes but I haven't forgotten what Napoleonic Wars is, a game. It needs to be fun for all involved.

If a small majority of Cav players want to make the experience worse for everyone else, of course we won't agree.

[Enderby]

Tbh we should just give the cav players admin horses since they seem to be disabled in general disadvantaged on foot

People who don't arrive will have good reason to complain after this without saying that maybe they are just not arrive personally 

[Enderby]

To be honest with regards to Arty, a vote was done but wasn't done with all the signed up teams? We were never included in the vote unless one of my guys has gone rogue

cav shouldn't dismount during all charge, as simple as that

I can't agree with this at all. Even dismounted a cav player is at a large advantage to an infantry player, especially in a more casual environment.

With all due respect, you didn't play much cavalry to say that, a cavalryman doesn't stand a chance in 1v1 mounted against a bayonet, he'll be dismounted and killed instantly thanks to his range, take my word for it 

I played and lead cavalry long before I made my own infantry regiment so thats not quite true  We are talking about the All Charge only here. I am well aware who has what advantage in a 1v1 between an Infantry player and a cav player.

With respect to you, because I also have no clue who you are, there is a reason why having cav dismount etc. became a thing. Its not just out of a hatred from infantry players. When the all charge is called and cohesion is lost, the point is for it to be an equal playing field for everyone left to the best of the admins ability. So that everyone gets a chance providing you are not dead already. Thats not the only reason, but honestly its the only reason needed.

If we were to have a season without all-charge, it would be shit.

I see, so go to play all inf, this is a GF now, not a event after this there are several classes, you have to accept it, the advantages as well as the disadvantages. You forgot the very principle of the game: Napoleonic wars.

Yes but I haven't forgotten what Napoleonic Wars is, a game. It needs to be fun for all involved.

If a small majority of Cav players want to make the experience worse for everyone else, of course we won't agree.

The cav is the bad boy when people don't arrive, but what is the reverse? This discussion is pointless.

[Saitama]

Tbh we should just give the cav players admin horses since they seem to be disabled in general disadvantaged on foot

People who don't arrive will have good reason to complain after this without saying that maybe they are just not arrive personally 

I hope people arrive if people not arrive personally!

[John Price]

Lmao stop trolling people with worse Englando than you 

[tommyxd]

To be honest with regards to Arty, a vote was done but wasn't done with all the signed up teams? We were never included in the vote unless one of my guys has gone rogue

cav shouldn't dismount during all charge, as simple as that

I can't agree with this at all. Even dismounted a cav player is at a large advantage to an infantry player, especially in a more casual environment.

With all due respect, you didn't play much cavalry to say that, a cavalryman doesn't stand a chance in 1v1 mounted against a bayonet, he'll be dismounted and killed instantly thanks to his range, take my word for it 

I played and lead cavalry long before I made my own infantry regiment so thats not quite true  We are talking about the All Charge only here. I am well aware who has what advantage in a 1v1 between an Infantry player and a cav player.

With respect to you, because I also have no clue who you are, there is a reason why having cav dismount etc. became a thing. Its not just out of a hatred from infantry players. When the all charge is called and cohesion is lost, the point is for it to be an equal playing field for everyone left to the best of the admins ability. So that everyone gets a chance providing you are not dead already. Thats not the only reason, but honestly its the only reason needed.

If we were to have a season without all-charge, it would be shit.

I see, so go to play all inf, this is a GF now, not a event after this there are several classes, you have to accept it, the advantages as well as the disadvantages. You forgot the very principle of the game: Napoleonic wars.

Yes but I haven't forgotten what Napoleonic Wars is, a game. It needs to be fun for all involved.

If a small majority of Cav players want to make the experience worse for everyone else, of course we won't agree.

might as well remove cav from the tournament then lol, this isn't a casual event and most people work together and all charge the majority of the time isn't a chaotic mess (if it is it's your fault lmao) like in casual events so handicapping cav further is just retarded and this is just people complaining cause they are too shit to kill a dude on a horse (which shouldn't be that hard in 2022)

[Enderby]

Tbh we should just give the cav players admin horses since they seem to be disabled in general disadvantaged on foot

People who don't arrive will have good reason to complain after this without saying that maybe they are just not arrive personally 

I hope people arrive if people not arrive personally!

I'm talking about personal skill, people criticize and want more rules without looking for a second if the problem is not theirs, i without the trolls start coming, so have a nice day 

[Enderby]

To be honest with regards to Arty, a vote was done but wasn't done with all the signed up teams? We were never included in the vote unless one of my guys has gone rogue

cav shouldn't dismount during all charge, as simple as that

I can't agree with this at all. Even dismounted a cav player is at a large advantage to an infantry player, especially in a more casual environment.

With all due respect, you didn't play much cavalry to say that, a cavalryman doesn't stand a chance in 1v1 mounted against a bayonet, he'll be dismounted and killed instantly thanks to his range, take my word for it 

I played and lead cavalry long before I made my own infantry regiment so thats not quite true  We are talking about the All Charge only here. I am well aware who has what advantage in a 1v1 between an Infantry player and a cav player.

With respect to you, because I also have no clue who you are, there is a reason why having cav dismount etc. became a thing. Its not just out of a hatred from infantry players. When the all charge is called and cohesion is lost, the point is for it to be an equal playing field for everyone left to the best of the admins ability. So that everyone gets a chance providing you are not dead already. Thats not the only reason, but honestly its the only reason needed.

If we were to have a season without all-charge, it would be shit.

I see, so go to play all inf, this is a GF now, not a event after this there are several classes, you have to accept it, the advantages as well as the disadvantages. You forgot the very principle of the game: Napoleonic wars.

Yes but I haven't forgotten what Napoleonic Wars is, a game. It needs to be fun for all involved.

If a small majority of Cav players want to make the experience worse for everyone else, of course we won't agree.

might as well remove cav from the tournament then lol, this isn't a casual event and most people work together and all charge the majority of the time isn't a chaotic mess (if it is it's your fault lmao) like in casual events so handicapping cav further is just retarded and this is just people complaining cause they are too shit to kill a dude on a horse (which shouldn't be that hard in 2022)

Exactly

[John Price]

Aight I'm out nobody here is capable of producing brain cells and it won't go anywhere anyway.

@Stoiki, nobody is talking about handicapping cav further except you.