Its stupid to take away points from a team due to 1 persons mistake. There is literally no point in a tournament if teams start getting points they did not win. If Freezy was using like god mode or something then I would say yah that was an unfair cheat and they should get the points. But it only shows health on a scoreboard... Its not like it gave an advantage to the entire 1er. True he should be banned as it was against the rules... but don't punish the entire 1er because of that.
That's indeed a bit harsh, but it is the punishment the rules request.
"3) If a player is found to have cheated in any of these ways during a match then that player's regiments will forfeit the match.
4) Using the hp clientside modification is not allowed under any circumstances."
Admins already discussed changing this rule but regardless of any changes, new rules cant be applied to old matches. So for our case the rules clearly states how to punish the use of this mod.
I do wonder whether goodest feels that its worth it to risk ruining the league just so the 2lr can place 5th instead of 6th
I dont see how i risk ruining this league, as it wasnt me cheating. I am just pointing out the rules someone else broke.
I really cant see why you are accusing me of risking to ruin the league.
I am pointing out that we are in the same situation as Nr. 4 but they got awarded the victory and we didnt.
I even tried to solve this without making it public and did it all in the referee steam chat but that didnt seem to help as it got never has been mentioned anywhere.
All I'm doing is pointing out a unjustified decision caused because someone else broke a rule.
I didnt do anything wrong here and yet I am trying to bring more ppl. in for the next matches as it is what lindblom said was the purpose of the tournament.
It's an unlucky timing for the comment that we always bring less than needed because that might have been true in the past and somehow is true for the last match as we only had 12 (not intentionally) but we decided to change that and play with everyone. I couldnt prove that because we havent had our second match yet (what I meant with unlucky timing) but I am definetly not trying to harm the league. I even changed our plans based on feedback I recieved from 1er after our match to improve the league or rather to do my part in making it what lindblom wanted it to be. But once again... all this is already said in my first statement.
Why would I even be a ref if I wantde to ruin this league?