Windflower wanted me to post this so here
I would say the problem with us reviewing trades is that everyone has a different opinion on who is better than who. People value people different, including the staff. I don't think any of the captains will be actually retarded to trade like camden for yoshie or something ridiculous. If there is something like that that comes up then by all means, go ahead and stop it; however, if both captains agree it should be allowed. Each captain agrees to a trade for a reason, mainly being they think the trade benefits them in some way (which is the point of trades). With reviewing trades, staff gets to give their personal input on player skill and value when the captains could see it differently. Like a captain wanting to trade and sees this person as a asset for their team, but it's blocked by someone not on the team, etc.