Dead

[Shadey]

First off, thanks Ciiges for going on with such an 'unrewarding' task. Appreciated.

Secondly, I‘ll try to give an opinion as unbiased as I can.

I‘ll start at the 'lower points':

Adds

I‘d add Vaggelaros (Greek/11e), Law (French/Nr.4), Zocki (German/2Lr), Recker (German/2Lr), Jaguar (German/Nr.4), St0m (German/Nr.6), Dominik (German/Nr.6), Griff (Turkish/11e), DerKaiser (?/11e), Hungarian (!/Nr.6).

[close]

80-85

I‘d put Skillerbro, Enderby, Husarion, Lindblom, Uganda, SteFan and Krishna higher. Krishna way higher, tbh. Since he always provides good results with a ping of 140+, nuff' said in my opinion.

Harford lower (sorry darling), Musketeer, Alexisse off the list.

[close]

86-87

Tomas, Mono, Quinn, DeLaBedoyere higher.

(Sorry but) I‘d put Andros, Shadey, Cage, Killa, Kazi, Nicolas Soult, Tulkas, Maxence, Yoran, Voland at least one point lower.

[close]

Spicy rest

Soartex, Rival, Stannis & prob Mark one point lower.

Hannes should be at least 93 points - shortly because he really earns it, but I could list some points for better understanding if needed. Better than just spamming random screenshots with good kd's (which is simply pathetic imo).

[close]

This is the very first stuff that popped into my mind, I will surely give some more feedback in the future. Btw, what about some more lists, like 'Top 10 blocker‘, 'Top 10 on the ground', 'Top 10 ctrl j user' etc. . They don‘t have to be in a particular order, tbf.

Don’t forgot TOP 10 Q’rs 

[Ciiges]

Appreciated lots dokletian, this is really helpfull and I will get to it tonight when I'm home. Thanks lots!

[Ciiges]

I've added most of your changes because I agree to most of them.

-I've moved Hannes to 92 instead of 93 because he's just got a +3 within 2 weeks so if he keeps performing he'll keep going up.
-I'm in need of a greek banner if anyone has it, please send :[
-I've added the new guys in the 81 list just for simplicity sake, I'll keep very close eyes on them and rate them accurately throughout the CCL.

Big thanks again Dok.

[MechIsGod]

Kaiser is Romanian btw

[stevve]

86-87

Tomas, Mono, Quinn, DeLaBedoyere higher.

(Sorry but) I‘d put Andros, Shadey, Cage, Killa, Kazi, Nicolas Soult, Tulkas, Maxence, Yoran, Voland at least one point lower.

[close]

Isn't Shadey (one of) the best in the 11e rn? I mean, he is carrying in 1v1s and at all his skill is top notch. An 89 rating doesn't seem so wrong to me.

[Ciiges]

86-87

Tomas, Mono, Quinn, DeLaBedoyere higher.

(Sorry but) I‘d put Andros, Shadey, Cage, Killa, Kazi, Nicolas Soult, Tulkas, Maxence, Yoran, Voland at least one point lower.

[close]

Isn't Shadey (one of) the best in the 11e rn? I mean, he is carrying in 1v1s and at all his skill is top notch. An 89 rating doesn't seem so wrong to me.

Ngl, you rated Thyrell  89 not too long ago, so you're input on this isn't as much respected as Doks. Besides, he still is rated as one of the highest 11e's with 87, that's very impressive still from 84 in 3 weeks

[MajorMark]

I agree on most of the changes proposed by Dok.
Northern can be removed from the list. I would add Myoui/Demme (German, 11e) & LaPierre (French, 3e)
I would also put Naz, Krishna, Hungarian, Law and St0m atleast one point higher.

This is how the list of top-15 players should look like in my opinion:

Spoiler

94 – Remao
93 – Dokletian
93 – Hannes
92 – Ouranos
92 – Stannis
91 – Destrass
91 – Rival
91 - Ciiges
90 – Blader
90 – Caucasian
90 - MajorMark
90 – Bedoyere
90 – Kazi
90 – Soartex
89 - Shadey

[close]

[Ciiges]

Thanks for the detailed opinion, always welcomed! However, some of those players either don't play hussar anymore, or don't play at all anymore, hence the current standings. I'll keep them in mind as the CCL progresses though.

Raised Krishna again because of a lot of requests, I do agree the guy performs insanely good.
I will also go ahead and completely remove Ouranous and rival to stop confusion as they dont play hussar or NW (rival) anymore.

[Tardet]

Destrass is really busy with IRL and only can attend a few 5e matches from time to time but I am not sure I would consider him an active player. Same goes for Rival, sure he is mechanically insane and if he is bothered to come back actively one day, no doubt he would top the rankings again, however, given the last conversation I had with him, I highly doubt we'll see this happening anytime soon.

I think the same can be said about a few players on the list but imo its more problematic to keep someone who is barely playing around 90+.

Edit: Just so your edit and missed the last sentence in the post above so nevermind that!

[Dokletian]

What about a section of like "Legends" (or whatever you wanna call it), where all the retired players are.

[SwissGronkh]

What about a section of like "Legends" (or whatever you wanna call it), where all the retired players are.

+1

[Ciiges]

Can deffo do that, will need some of u grandpa players to help me with that though

[MajorMark]

What about a section of like "Legends" (or whatever you wanna call it), where all the retired players are.

+1

Edit: Ouranos still plays in the 3e and on the cav groupfighting server as hussar, just not in the CCL.

[Tardet]

What about a section of like "Legends" (or whatever you wanna call it), where all the retired players are.

Definitely a good idea. I also suggested some ideas to Ciiges such as different categories/strengths like Mapple did for his NA All Time list. I feel like rating players with a number is a good way to compare people easily but adding categories help to show what a player is really good at (smart delaying, surviving, aggressive or defensive plays, clutch potential, movements, dismounted skill vs mounted players, mounted skills vs dismounted players, and many more ..).

However, its a lot of work to keep it up to date, whereas a Legend category is entertaining, easier to do and isn't going to require that many updates with time.

[Shadey]

What about a section of like "Legends" (or whatever you wanna call it), where all the retired players are.

Definitely a good idea. I also suggested some ideas to Ciiges such as different categories/strengths like Mapple did for his NA All Time list. I feel like rating players with a number is a good way to compare people easily but adding categories help to show what a player is really good at (smart delaying, surviving, aggressive or defensive plays, clutch potential, movements, dismounted skill vs mounted players, mounted skills vs dismounted players, and many more ..).

However, its a lot of work to keep it up to date, whereas a Legend category is entertaining, easier to do and isn't going to require that many updates with time.

Great idea, would take a lot of work though