North American Community Lists - NaCl [UPDATE 1.1: "Show Some Melee Competence"]

[BabyJesus]

I am thinking of setting up a permanent council for the melee rankings. Well known skilled players would be major sources of input for ranking updates. Ideally 1-2 council members for every interested regiment. Non council members can still give input. Thoughts? Suggesting this because I get accused of bias so often, so maybe this will give some peace of mind

Will you actually listen to this council instead of putting your fingers in ur ears and saying everyone is wrong like you did in TS that one time? :L

I listened to all of your opinions. The current list is community made, not Grimsight made, just like it will be in the future. Yes I had a disagreement of the teamspeaks opinion on 1 player. Sue me.

im guessing it was blood who everyone said shouldn't be a 93

stop lieing. I never said that. Blood is nuts.

says the guy that was given points for "good communication"

[Commander Bondage]

Why is bondage not on alltime leaders

[Coconut]

Heres some memes for u guys

Spoiler

[close]

[Kovyjack]

says the guy that was given points for "good communication"

Mic spam*

[Theodin]

Coconut where the fuck was me getting rekt? Jesus learn your memes.
Uh, and, i'd be down to be on that melee council. Me and Russian will rep the 71st, mkay?

[BabyJesus]

Coconut where the fuck was me getting rekt? Jesus learn your memes.
Uh, and, i'd be down to be on that melee council. Me and Russian will rep the 71st, mkay?

lets just be honest, no one wants you on that council

[Theodin]

Coconut where the fuck was me getting rekt? Jesus learn your memes.
Uh, and, i'd be down to be on that melee council. Me and Russian will rep the 71st, mkay?

lets just be honest, no one wants you on that council

y tho, i'm not selfish about my rankings, i'd put myself anywhere between an 85-88, and i've been ranked there, so i'm happy
I do know quite a bit about people skill and what ranking they should deserve

[JackieChan]

Heres some memes for u guys

Spoiler

[close]

lol ahahah

This thread escalated pretty quickly last night, holy shit haha.

[BabyJesus]

Coconut where the fuck was me getting rekt? Jesus learn your memes.
Uh, and, i'd be down to be on that melee council. Me and Russian will rep the 71st, mkay?

lets just be honest, no one wants you on that council

y tho, i'm not selfish about my rankings, i'd put myself anywhere between an 85-88, and i've been ranked there, so i'm happy
I do know quite a bit about people skill and what ranking they should deserve

your really like a 75 tho

[JackieChan]

Coconut where the fuck was me getting rekt? Jesus learn your memes.
Uh, and, i'd be down to be on that melee council. Me and Russian will rep the 71st, mkay?

lets just be honest, no one wants you on that council

y tho, i'm not selfish about my rankings, i'd put myself anywhere between an 85-88, and i've been ranked there, so i'm happy
I do know quite a bit about people skill and what ranking they should deserve

your really like a 75 tho

Wrong. Theo shouldn't be on the list, since he never shows up to events and we thus can't rank him. #rekt

[AP0CALYPS3]

Heres some memes for u guys

Spoiler

[close]

i like this meme

[BabyJesus]

Can someone explain to me why everyone thinks this list is just based on dueling and ft7s?

[GeneralSquirts]

Can someone explain to me why everyone thinks this list is official and not coming from the opinion of one individual.

[KillerShark]

Can someone explain to me why everyone thinks this list is just based on dueling and ft7s?

Well tournamets don't really show how good of a player you are to someone else. Let's say Jackie faced Tammo and Tammo won, but in the finals Pinoy beat Tammo. Jackie could beat Pinoy, so if it wasn't for Tammo Jackie would have won the tournament. If that was in the first round someone could easily say "Wow. Jackie sucks dick because he lost in the first round", when really he could be the champion. Dueling in a ft7 shows how a person does against everyone's fighting style individually and can be applied to the community as a whole. Just my opinion.

[BabyJesus]

Can someone explain to me why everyone thinks this list is just based on dueling and ft7s?

Well tournamets don't really show how good of a player you are to someone else. Let's say Jackie faced Tammo and Tammo won, but in the finals Pinoy beat Tammo. Jackie could beat Pinoy, so if it wasn't for Tammo Jackie would have won the tournament. If that was in the first round someone could easily say "Wow. Jackie sucks dick because he lost in the first round", when really he could be the champion. Dueling in a ft7 shows how a person does against everyone's fighting style individually and can be applied to the community as a whole. Just my opinion.

But is groupfighting not important or something? I always thought groupfighting was way more important than dueling, since you know line battles are about groupfights and not just who can win the most duels.

I do think tournaments count for to much on this list. Like i probably wouldnt even be on here if it wasnt for my tourney win