North American Napoleonic Wars League [Seasons 1-3; Locked]

[Mockingjay]

A screencap of the conversation me an Alex had, to get rid of the drama.

Spoiler

[close]

[Shine]

I don't get what there is to review, a merc was obviously used and that isn't allowed according to Rule 20:

20. - Invites are NOT allowed; if we find out that a regiment played with invites, we will remove a win and 3 points and the opposing regiment, if it lost, will be given the win

Both of you should stop whining, arguing, and posting steam conversations on the thread though.

Correct me if I'm wrong, I've literally never been to a NANWL match before so I may not know what I'm talking about.

[~NickCole~]

I think this is correct. Mercs are not supposed to be used in the NWL

[Salt]

Well wait, so was Mang double regging in the 35th, or was he mercing? Because if he's on their roster and his other regiment is not in the league, then I don't believe it's against the rules.

[potus]

if a merc was used then yes enforce rule 20
and double regimenting is not allowed either if i am not mistaken

for the rest keep partying!! tomorrowland whoo yeah! xD

[Mockingjay]

Mang is double regging in the 35th, and he is on the roster. He is in the 51st and the 35th, but because the 51st is not in NWL he is allowed to attend NWL matches with the 35th.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1J0shpw8TZJbFx3D2NWtZJm_Y7CBLIMbfIS-dwEyTuNk/pubhtml

[Salt]

and double regimenting is not allowed either if i am not mistaken

Being in 2 or more regiments that participate in this League is against the rules!

51st isnt in NWL, cause they are bad

I think double regging is^

If it isn't, then go ahead and vacate some wins from the 2te, because one of our members (Zach_Attack) is in the PLG, but was also cleared to play with us by Jackie because the PLG does not participate in this league. Now if Mang merced, then by all means punish him, but if he really is a part of both the 51st and the 35th, then I fail to see where the rules are broken.

[Chantakey]

Mang is double regging in the 35th, and he is on the roster. He is in the 51st and the 35th, but because the 51st is not in NWL he is allowed to attend NWL matches with the 35th.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1J0shpw8TZJbFx3D2NWtZJm_Y7CBLIMbfIS-dwEyTuNk/pubhtml

he wasnt double reging until we busted him out.

[Ryner]

Can we just agree to disagree and bar Mang from participating in NWL related matches... give it two weeks and he'll join an entirely different group of regiments.

[Alexander]

Mang is double regging in the 35th, and he is on the roster. He is in the 51st and the 35th, but because the 51st is not in NWL he is allowed to attend NWL matches with the 35th.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1J0shpw8TZJbFx3D2NWtZJm_Y7CBLIMbfIS-dwEyTuNk/pubhtml

The main focus is on having fun while being competitive and seeing where your regiments is compared to others.

That is the second sentence of the last paragraph. I think the rule should be changed and we be given consultation. This league is to show how good your regiment is against others. Not a 2v1. Mang is the 51st since that regiment is shit. We all know that. So he joins the 35th just to beat me after one of his guys was kicked out and joined us. He told me that via steam chat above. But that is beside the point. Im just saying if this is a regiment vs regiment comp others should not be allowed to merc. A 0% Tolerance. How come 2 regiments can come together just to beat one? It is just not right.

Edit: The refernce in the first sentence is from the Introduction

[Chantakey]

Can we just agree to disagree and bar Mang from participating in NWL related matches... give it two weeks and he'll join an entirely different group of regiments.

Its funny because he was a 5th members last week and 51st and now a 35th kinda funny he didn't participate in our NWL he left the 3rd day after he joined.

[cheeseypants]

The distinction here is clearly between rule 20 and rule 30.  If Mang actually joined the 35th, double regging or not, that would make him not an invite.

The 51st (Mang's Reg) does not compete in NANWL, so by rule 30, it is allowed. 

[Commander Bondage]

Honestly, the rules should be reviewed. I think they're conflicted. That's all I have to say about this matter.

[Zzehth]

but if he really is a part of both the 51st and the 35th, then I fail to see where the rules are broken.

^


51st is not in NWL, there is no problem. 

2 days ago, a 35th member (I dont remember who) asked Jackie if it would be ok if Mang plays for 35th... Jackie said ok.

Still going to talk to Jackie about that rule, and if in case it changes.. the matches already played will not be changed, since there was no problem.

[Marceaux]

Honestly, the rules should be reviewed. I think they're conflicted. That's all I have to say about this matter.

+1