Flying Squirrel Entertainment

Mount & Blade Warband: Napoleonic Wars => Community => Events: NA => Topic started by: Fartknocker on December 27, 2018, 08:38:42 pm

Title: Melee Only Event
Post by: Fartknocker on December 27, 2018, 08:38:42 pm
We need an event that focuses on melee so we can introduce casual regiments to the more skilled and in my opinion more fun aspect of the game. I think a melee-only conquest or capture the flag event would be perfect. We used to do this in the 63e after training to practice and also for fun. It is a good way for casual regiments to get a taste of what a groupfight would be like. This could also introduce more new players to servers like BoB Groupfighting or BBG Duel.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Hawkince on December 27, 2018, 08:42:27 pm
We need an event that focuses on melee so we can introduce casual regiments to the more skilled and in my opinion more fun aspect of the game. I think a melee-only conquest or capture the flag event would be perfect. We used to do this in the 63e after training to practice and also for fun. It is a good way for casual regiments to get a taste of what a groupfight would be like. This could also introduce more new players to servers like BoB Groupfighting or BBG Duel.

I as the future Com Rep endorse this idea
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: ~Midnight~ on December 27, 2018, 08:47:01 pm
On EU there was a melee only siege. It was quite enjoyable imo. Not a lot of people enjoyed it though.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Fartknocker on December 27, 2018, 08:59:05 pm
On EU there was a melee only siege. It was quite enjoyable imo. Not a lot of people enjoyed it though.

I wonder if it was the siege part or the map design that people didn't like. Or just that they didn't like melee.

I feel like conquest is pretty well suited for melee only because it will be like small groupfights for parts of land. Survivors would have to hold out in that spot against waves of enemies, and good players could make a big impact. It would be interesting to see.

Good maps make a huge difference also. The long time running back just to get killed again is what I think would turn most people off. If there was a way to make things more fast paced I think it would be better.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Suns on December 27, 2018, 09:07:59 pm
we need this.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: tired on December 27, 2018, 10:07:10 pm
why don't you try hosting a king of the hill mode game event and just set melee only to on.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Moraine on December 27, 2018, 11:05:13 pm
These were called line only events but I'm afraid anything like that isn't going to go down well most casual regiment's don't even go on group fighting or duel servers
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Fartknocker on December 27, 2018, 11:41:09 pm
These were called line only events but I'm afraid anything like that isn't going to go down well most casual regiment's don't even go on group fighting or duel servers

Part of what I think this will do is encourage more casual players to go on those servers. Melee is more fun than getting shot and waiting 15 minutes and if it's done right hopefully players would see that.

why don't you try hosting a king of the hill mode game event and just set melee only to on.

I don't have the time, server, or experience to organize one which is why I'd like to see someone else run it. If a group of us got together to figure it out I think we could.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Risk_ on December 27, 2018, 11:47:05 pm
old causal events were so much better. you didn't have to wait 15mins dead because of the hill camping. that has been happening in pub events since like mid-late 2017 so much. I use to merc a lot months ago and there were only 3 rounds in one event every week like that is so boring and annoying. before you could do several round that lasted about under 10min and get like 6-8 rounds. think these were the line only events though. it's just so boring with a round being 15min of hill camping. part of it to is the admins. besides a few, most admins let that happen and that is why it continues to happen.

maybe i should host a line only event
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: |Viper| on December 27, 2018, 11:50:41 pm
Sounds fun.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: MATT123456789 on December 28, 2018, 01:07:08 am
The reason this will not work, is because the noobs will get absolutely swamped by veteran melee'ers.

Many times I have been on duels or groupfight with one or two other players who were obviously new to the game and I just kill them 20 times in a row and they quit the game out of frustration because it's not fun when you lose 99 percent of the time.

We could make this work though, if we had a ranking system like CSGO, to put the noobs with the noobs, the average with the average, and the pros with the pros.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Pinoy12 on December 28, 2018, 01:35:03 am
The reason this will not work, is because the noobs will get absolutely swamped by veteran melee'ers.

Many times I have been on duels or groupfight with one or two other players who were obviously new to the game and I just kill them 20 times in a row and they quit the game out of frustration because it's not fun when you lose 99 percent of the time.

We could make this work though, if we had a ranking system like CSGO, to put the noobs with the noobs, the average with the average, and the pros with the pros.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: ~NickCole~ on December 28, 2018, 01:52:52 am
old causal events were so much better. you didn't have to wait 15mins dead because of the hill camping. that has been happening in pub events since like mid-late 2017 so much. I use to merc a lot months ago and there were only 3 rounds in one event every week like that is so boring and annoying. before you could do several round that lasted about under 10min and get like 6-8 rounds. think these were the line only events though. it's just so boring with a round being 15min of hill camping. part of it to is the admins. besides a few, most admins let that happen and that is why it continues to happen.

maybe i should host a line only event
Events now does a time limit every round before an All-Charge is called. Me and Vetro tried hosting a line only months ago and only got 3 regiments to do it but if you can find enough regs then host it.

The reason this will not work, is because the noobs will get absolutely swamped by veteran melee'ers.

Many times I have been on duels or groupfight with one or two other players who were obviously new to the game and I just kill them 20 times in a row and they quit the game out of frustration because it's not fun when you lose 99 percent of the time.

We could make this work though, if we had a ranking system like CSGO, to put the noobs with the noobs, the average with the average, and the pros with the pros.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Suns on December 28, 2018, 02:00:11 am
The reason this will not work, is because the noobs will get absolutely swamped by veteran melee'ers.

Many times I have been on duels or groupfight with one or two other players who were obviously new to the game and I just kill them 20 times in a row and they quit the game out of frustration because it's not fun when you lose 99 percent of the time.

We could make this work though, if we had a ranking system like CSGO, to put the noobs with the noobs, the average with the average, and the pros with the pros.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: |Viper| on December 28, 2018, 02:00:34 am
The reason this will not work, is because the noobs will get absolutely swamped by veteran melee'ers.

Many times I have been on duels or groupfight with one or two other players who were obviously new to the game and I just kill them 20 times in a row and they quit the game out of frustration because it's not fun when you lose 99 percent of the time.

We could make this work though, if we had a ranking system like CSGO, to put the noobs with the noobs, the average with the average, and the pros with the pros.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: tired on December 28, 2018, 02:08:01 am
or if it was teams, you can make teams fair. If bad players had good players on their team they might not care, especially if it was 100v100. lol you know what, we could try a version of this on Bot Survival, like on a Friday night, do 20 elite players vs 50-80, on melee only. That might be hilarious.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Fartknocker on December 28, 2018, 02:09:24 am
or if it was teams, you can make teams fair. If bad players had good players on their team they might not care, especially if it was 100v100. lol you know what, we could try a version of this on Bot Survival, like on a Friday night, do 20 elite players vs 50-80, on melee only. That might be hilarious.

That would be perfect lmao
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: BabyJesus on December 28, 2018, 02:10:20 am
old causal events were so much better. you didn't have to wait 15mins dead because of the hill camping. that has been happening in pub events since like mid-late 2017 so much. I use to merc a lot months ago and there were only 3 rounds in one event every week like that is so boring and annoying. before you could do several round that lasted about under 10min and get like 6-8 rounds. think these were the line only events though. it's just so boring with a round being 15min of hill camping. part of it to is the admins. besides a few, most admins let that happen and that is why it continues to happen.

maybe i should host a line only event
this is why I actually started to hate casual events. Like you got shot early or something you are literally just spectating for 20 minutes to do it again next round
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Suns on December 28, 2018, 02:12:32 am
lolyep why i quit casual events years ago
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Jakester on December 28, 2018, 05:22:35 am
old causal events were so much better. you didn't have to wait 15mins dead because of the hill camping. that has been happening in pub events since like mid-late 2017 so much. I use to merc a lot months ago and there were only 3 rounds in one event every week like that is so boring and annoying. before you could do several round that lasted about under 10min and get like 6-8 rounds. think these were the line only events though. it's just so boring with a round being 15min of hill camping. part of it to is the admins. besides a few, most admins let that happen and that is why it continues to happen.

maybe i should host a line only event

Even as late as when I hosted my event we always got through two maps of three rounds each, and usually played a third map with two rounds. Not sure which hosts are the ones who are unable to get through two and a half maps but they should definitely be doing better than that.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Risk_ on December 28, 2018, 05:42:52 am
old causal events were so much better. you didn't have to wait 15mins dead because of the hill camping. that has been happening in pub events since like mid-late 2017 so much. I use to merc a lot months ago and there were only 3 rounds in one event every week like that is so boring and annoying. before you could do several round that lasted about under 10min and get like 6-8 rounds. think these were the line only events though. it's just so boring with a round being 15min of hill camping. part of it to is the admins. besides a few, most admins let that happen and that is why it continues to happen.

maybe i should host a line only event

Even as late as when I hosted my event we always got through two maps of three rounds each, and usually played a third map with two rounds. Not sure which hosts are the ones who are unable to get through two and a half maps but they should definitely be doing better than that.

pretty much all the events besides yours and maybe 1 other.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Windflower on December 31, 2018, 04:48:55 pm
or if it was teams, you can make teams fair. If bad players had good players on their team they might not care, especially if it was 100v100. lol you know what, we could try a version of this on Bot Survival, like on a Friday night, do 20 elite players vs 50-80, on melee only. That might be hilarious.
We should to this tonight! (or next friday) It would be a good run to see if we could pull it off with the casuals and make a real event with it. It's possible with regiments I think you just have to balance them correctly, and there's not too too many vet. players I would say that would just murder everyone.

Spoiler
old causal events were so much better. you didn't have to wait 15mins dead because of the hill camping. that has been happening in pub events since like mid-late 2017 so much. I use to merc a lot months ago and there were only 3 rounds in one event every week like that is so boring and annoying. before you could do several round that lasted about under 10min and get like 6-8 rounds. think these were the line only events though. it's just so boring with a round being 15min of hill camping. part of it to is the admins. besides a few, most admins let that happen and that is why it continues to happen.

maybe i should host a line only event

Even as late as when I hosted my event we always got through two maps of three rounds each, and usually played a third map with two rounds. Not sure which hosts are the ones who are unable to get through two and a half maps but they should definitely be doing better than that.
[close]

pretty much all the events besides yours and maybe 1 other.
Specialties mayne, I think people lost interest in Line Only but I would like to see one, the last one I remember is the 63e's.. We should host one or the other though we right
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Oatmeal on December 31, 2018, 09:39:03 pm
legend has it there was a melee only event where billthebutcher 1v80'd a line of elite players and won without taking a single hit
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Suns on December 31, 2018, 10:02:10 pm
legend has it there was a melee only event where billthebutcher 1v80'd a line of elite players and won without taking a single hit
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Moraine on January 01, 2019, 12:53:03 am
I think things like PUG's are a pretty good after event alternative if they're hosted again.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Unitater on January 01, 2019, 12:59:59 am
I think things like PUG's are a pretty good after event alternative if they're hosted again.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Fartknocker on January 01, 2019, 08:31:33 pm
PUG’s are PUG’s. We need something to introduce the casual regiments to the melee side of the game.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Yvrul on January 01, 2019, 08:38:32 pm
old causal events were so much better. you didn't have to wait 15mins dead because of the hill camping. that has been happening in pub events since like mid-late 2017 so much. I use to merc a lot months ago and there were only 3 rounds in one event every week like that is so boring and annoying. before you could do several round that lasted about under 10min and get like 6-8 rounds. think these were the line only events though. it's just so boring with a round being 15min of hill camping. part of it to is the admins. besides a few, most admins let that happen and that is why it continues to happen.

maybe i should host a line only event

I am not sure what old casual events you are taking about, but 54th, 63e, 29th/9th, 24th/Nr9, LIR, 3te, Prussian Army and others all hillcamp back then. Some regiments would actually run to he edge of the map to avoid cavalry which caused events to last a lot longer. We use to barely get a second map finished on time.

Eventually things got better, when William left the 9th they started to work with other regiments and fight in middle but they disbanded shortly after. PSG where a good example of a regiment in casual events that didn’t hillcamp too hard same with the IXE. Nr9 eventually changed their ways too.
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Wastee on January 01, 2019, 09:12:03 pm
I want custom maps with wheat fields back so the LG can go back to ambushing pub regs
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Suns on January 01, 2019, 10:18:55 pm
I want custom maps with wheat fields back so the LG can go back to ambushing pub regs

LMFAO pinoy has a video of 57th doing that
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: BabyJesus on January 01, 2019, 10:23:23 pm
I think things like PUG's are a pretty good after event alternative if they're hosted again.
pugs are fine for a week or so but then everyone starts to troll

It would be nice if we had a system like fpl where they keep track of stats and then give out prizes at the end
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Glenn on January 01, 2019, 11:41:49 pm
I want custom maps with wheat fields back so the LG can go back to ambushing pub regs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rjQZHIiAIB4
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Fartknocker on January 02, 2019, 12:16:02 am
I want custom maps with wheat fields back so the LG can go back to ambushing pub regs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rjQZHIiAIB4

That was actually amazing
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Moraine on January 02, 2019, 02:35:58 am
Even if there were prizes would people even get them? To my knowledge WPC is still not over because it's being delayed so no one can get their prize?
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: Wastee on January 02, 2019, 05:22:50 am
Even if there were prizes would people even get them? To my knowledge WPC is still not over because it's being delayed so no one can get their prize?
We're still getting our prize. It just hasn't happened because none of the days I offered worked for everyone on the other team and I'm out of town for the Holidays
Title: Re: Melee Only Event
Post by: No0B on January 10, 2019, 12:17:36 am
a custom map's would be badass