| NW 2v2 | Season II | Match-Week 7 (Final)

[Lonedoge.]

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

[[Stryker]]

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue Edit: If they were running around the map and not shooting/engaging at all I'd agree with you but we were shooting

[[2ndHess] lukasoh]

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue

You had 10 mins to shoot and made like 3 kills? Lets play another 50 mins until you shoot everyone across the map.

[Saxon]

6-2 to 45thN.

Some general points about this match, a lot of FiC/FoL but not a lot of deaths from it and no rule break was seriously round changing imo. I called 1 all charge round where 11 minutes had passed with little action. Some dubious charges but overall nothing that would of changed the overall result of the match.



https://imgur.com/a/g3usytB

https://imgur.com/a/p1snQ0M

[Lonedoge.]

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue

good leading/repositioning to get shots is fine, running away while not trying to get any shots at all is just a waste of time and delaying the inevitable

[Saxon]

Spoiler

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue

You had 10 mins to shoot and made like 3 kills? Lets play another 50 mins until you shoot everyone across the map.

[close]

As I said in the game, over ten minutes had passed with little result coming from the shooting. Both lines were evasive, and the response was that it may of allowed you to beat 45thN Grens. But I am not playing 15+ minute rounds so you may or may not win a round

[[Stryker]]

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue

You had 10 mins to shoot and made like 3 kills? Lets play another 50 mins until you shoot everyone across the map.

Then order the regiments to get closer and if they don't they forfeit a round, don't let it be decided solely on melee skill

[Saxon]

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue

You had 10 mins to shoot and made like 3 kills? Lets play another 50 mins until you shoot everyone across the map.

Then order the regiments to get closer and if they don't they forfeit a round, don't let it be decided solely on melee skill

Rules say I can call all charge, nothing about me telling them to get closer.

[El_Presidente]

Spoiler

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue

You had 10 mins to shoot and made like 3 kills? Lets play another 50 mins until you shoot everyone across the map.

[close]

As I said in the game, over ten minutes had passed with little result coming from the shooting. Both lines were evasive, and the response was that it may of allowed you to beat 45thN Grens. But I am not playing 15+ minute rounds so you may or may not win a round

Really? Did you forget we killed half of their centre in melee that round before tactically withdrawing before the grens got us into melee?

Spoiler

[close]

What about this? Not charging 2 lines? You couldn't make it up.

Screenshots don't lie.

[Skittykiller]

All I have to say is we lost 2 rounds by admins. Thats all, I let Pres deal with this further if needed! And a line can only charge 1 line. not 1 45thN Grens did that like 3 times this whole match.

[Saxon]

I['m not really sure what you are trying to prove by that screenshot it isnt very clear.

But-

3.3  Regiments must stay together whilst in charge; individuals straying dramatically from the rest of their regiment (rambos) in an attempt to engage a 2nd enemy line will be slain without warning.

3.4  Charging two enemy units at once is only acceptable if either the two lines are in close proximity to one another or your regiment is of sufficient size to engage the 2nd line without breaking the rambo rule (above).

Anytime that two lines were charged, they were either close enough or the charger was of a large enough size to not be ramboing.

I just followed the rules set out, if you do not like them then speak to Kincaid. I do not think it is any secret me and maskman do not get along so I really hope there is no one thinking of me being bias

[ArtOfKilling]

From that screenshot, after that highlander ended melee, he joined up with the other 4+ highalnders and kept pursuing the other british line, the melee charge happened a lot after the time of this screenshot

[19boboy97]

I['m not really sure what you are trying to prove by that screenshot it isnt very clear.

But-

3.3  Regiments must stay together whilst in charge; individuals straying dramatically from the rest of their regiment (rambos) in an attempt to engage a 2nd enemy line will be slain without warning.

3.4  Charging two enemy units at once is only acceptable if either the two lines are in close proximity to one another or your regiment is of sufficient size to engage the 2nd line without breaking the rambo rule (above).

Anytime that two lines were charged, they were either close enough or the charger was of a large enough size to not be ramboing.

Yes we should stick together in charge, but we couldn't since you split into 1000 pieces running away.

[maskmanmarks]

Spoiler

10 min all charge rule is stupid

no its not, nobody wants to spend 20minutes every round chasing lines

They are engaging in shooting against a melee superior opponent, what's the issue

You had 10 mins to shoot and made like 3 kills? Lets play another 50 mins until you shoot everyone across the map.

[close]

As I said in the game, over ten minutes had passed with little result coming from the shooting. Both lines were evasive, and the response was that it may of allowed you to beat 45thN Grens. But I am not playing 15+ minute rounds so you may or may not win a round

Really? Did you forget we killed half of their centre in melee that round before tactically withdrawing before the grens got us into melee?

Spoiler

[close]

What about this? Not charging 2 lines? You couldn't make it up.

Screenshots don't lie.

GG WP thanks for the match

[Skittykiller]

Anytime that two lines were charged, they were either close enough or the charger was of a large enough size to not be ramboing.

45thN Gren line was always the ones charging 2 lines. They already werent the biggest line on the field. How are they a good size to still rambo??? 19th line Lines up once we were in melee. 19th shot and reloaded while the 45thN Grens were still charging them while charging us. 1 round 2-3 of my guys were Ficed and no slays or Revives. (Art Responded that his fingers couldnt do it fast enough?!?!?) While you do slay and revive them.