Indeed, as Melton said, also it was Gaz who almost tied with the 91st.
If you give Gaz players who played for him in the 5th NWL I am sure he would win it.
He only is unlucky because he has retards in his regiment (no offence, I am/was one of them too)
He actually tied with them once.
Having drew with 91st at one of their peaks and just about beat 77y at one of theirs, Gaz is a superior leader, I'm not even sure why that is in question. If anything, why is Aldemar so high up the list? His regiment split more than anyone elses and 84e's leading strength came from others (imo).
As for all-time regiments, how was the 22nd in any respect of the word better than 8Lr or even K-KA? I don't recall them winning anything, or providing anything. I think you's are really underestimating what 8Lr were like/brought to the table....And surely the Spartans are only on the list because of Obelix?