I will let relevant people judge the ratings but I do enjoy the fact you took the time to rate 70 players instead of 30-50 like other lists.
Galavant aka JackieChan is not a rising star, he's already one...
How is an Old Gen a Rising Star!?!?!?!?
He is an old gen that hasn't played/dominated in EU for years, literally playing in Division B atm so I'd say he fits in there even though the accolade will feel weird for most of us old farts. No doubt if Jackie keeps on playing, he will eventually get back to his former self and be capable to hold on against T1 opposition but that's just not quite the case at the moment.
I've only been playing for a bit over a month again now and I legit got spanked inviting for Invictus vs Animals yesterday, so I definitely don't deserve anything higher
I'm flattered just making the list, so thanks.