NA HoF Thread ♛

[Sgt.Winters]

Great now we are getting top-notch opinions from a fucking retirement home.

What's next? Vetro making a how to guide for intermittent fasting?

It's like asking Baboons to not throw their shit at each other in the name of peace and love. Horrible misapprehensions of a fucked caste system.

[Mexican]

retarded list

[~NickCole~]

Like I said before if you want to make a case for yourself or anyone else to move up or down on the list/ get added then feel free to either on here or steam.

[Wastee]

Like I said before if you want to make a case for yourself or anyone else to move up or down on the list/ get added then feel free to either on here or steam.

Well that too but the structure of having to open a new tab to view information and what not is really a downgrade. I always thought the record book idea was super cool and nice. Now it’s just another list really based off nothing but some opinions and hype

Also you gonna add that 4v4 tournament?

[Runepkyz]

2k15-18 is pretty off, most of those people that are on it didnt even play for like half of those years.

[Theodin]

Like I said before if you want to make a case for yourself or anyone else to move up or down on the list/ get added then feel free to either on here or steam.

Well that too but the structure of having to open a new tab to view information and what not is really a downgrade. I always thought the record book idea was super cool and nice. Now it’s just another list really based off nothing but some opinions and hype

Also you gonna add that 4v4 tournament?

Remember that Atomic had the goat coach

[Wastee]

I’ll have to look a little deeper into where people are placed but also based off what Risk said and my opinion lists like these should look more at impact than apparent skill. Anyone can do really well on Groupfighting just as really good people can troll and not try. If players haven’t proven they can compete at a high level they shouldn’t be high on a list

[Dan the Seagull Chef]

I don’t see a list of the greatest coaches of all time

[Theodin]

I don’t see a list of the greatest coaches of all time

Tragic

[Sleek]

I don't see a list of Mid players you hate to see it

[Moraine]

2k15-18 is pretty off, most of those people that are on it didnt even play for like half of those years.

[Sgt.Winters]

Just delete and redo the list, this is a catastrophe.

[Cwater]

The main problem (in my eyes) with this list is the lack of consistency and transparency in how player rankings are determined. Obviously tournament and league titles are held in some regard within this list; though I could not ascertain what relevance regimental league wins contain within the context of a melee list, but power to you. Yet, this is obviously not the sole contributing factor to a player's ranking, as players such as (but not limited to) Mang and Swerp would be much lower, and Wastee, Yoshie, and a multitude of others would be elevated several tiers. How much does a player's tenure within the game factor into the calculation, as players such have Jaax have had a relatively short period of time in which they have been dominant/good, yet still make the list. Or is this purely an aggregate of several other lists from varied sources? In the end I think the list would either benefit from a complete do-over with cemented rules for player rankings, or an explanation of any withstanding qualifying factors.

[Wastee]

The main problem (in my eyes) with this list is the lack of consistency and transparency in how player rankings are determined. Obviously tournament and league titles are held in some regard within this list; though I could not ascertain what relevance regimental league wins contain within the context of a melee list, but power to you. Yet, this is obviously not the sole contributing factor to a player's ranking, as players such as (but not limited to) Mang and Swerp would be much lower, and Wastee, Yoshie, and a multitude of others would be elevated several tiers. How much does a player's tenure within the game factor into the calculation, as players such have Jaax have had a relatively short period of time in which they have been dominant/good, yet still make the list. Or is this purely an aggregate of several other lists from varied sources? In the end I think the list would either benefit from a complete do-over with cemented rules for player rankings, or an explanation of any withstanding qualifying factors.

I didn’t know you were capable of sentences

[Sgt.Winters]

The main problem (in my eyes) with this list is the lack of consistency and transparency in how player rankings are determined. Obviously tournament and league titles are held in some regard within this list; though I could not ascertain what relevance regimental league wins contain within the context of a melee list, but power to you. Yet, this is obviously not the sole contributing factor to a player's ranking, as players such as (but not limited to) Mang and Swerp would be much lower, and Wastee, Yoshie, and a multitude of others would be elevated several tiers. How much does a player's tenure within the game factor into the calculation, as players such have Jaax have had a relatively short period of time in which they have been dominant/good, yet still make the list. Or is this purely an aggregate of several other lists from varied sources? In the end I think the list would either benefit from a complete do-over with cemented rules for player rankings, or an explanation of any withstanding qualifying factors.

I didn’t know you were capable of sentences

Are you kidding, this guy would read me Alexander Pope poems for bedtime stories.