Not fitting a theme doesn't make total sense, and people just quoting Deofuta without knowing what he's talking about are frankly being moronic. If it's a matter of size, it's a matter of size. Fitting the theme would, at most, mean some minor time spent re-organizing some bits here and there to make everything work. Most of the issue I assume would come from people's current avatars potentially bugging out a bit, but that would be resolved with new avatars, surely. I'd say it could be done if the admins took a few minutes away from developing BCoF to tinker with the forum layout. This is Simple Machines, right? Like, the super versatile forum format that everyone seems to use (at least FSE and TW)?
Poll added.
Poll