Retired Numbers

[CHARLES111MAC]

This is annoying me as i had fought to get the 51st name so i could lead it, what is annoying me is that before me marsh lead the regiment, Marsh is the stefiboy of EU he promissed not to fuck up and he did. But I i wanted to give it a go and lead the 51st. I made the thread had everything organised for me to go to sleep but then they introduced the new rule, the it is retired. I don't see the point in this as when a new person takes over a name he starts it over as in no history of the last one and there is an in- game unit of the 51st, so if i make a new light infantry unit i need to make a skin. All i wanted to do was lead the 51st Before marsh got it but he did and i sat by and waited since December 14 so basicaly a month or so to get it and now i have beend denied.

I made this for others to tell me if they think this is just or not. Not to argue at all.

[Odysseus]

I think it's stupid, yes. I do see the point in not tarnishing a name though... But my opinion still stands.

[CHARLES111MAC]

The thing i don't understand why not allow what happened to the 42nd a new Col came alon and what the old regiment done was like regarded as his regiment and that a new one came along it was his you know?

[34th Artimus]

I have to say that this in my honest opinion isn't a matter for the likes of FSE to discuss. People can do what they like, it's not up to FSE to demand that a regiment name/tag be off limits to everyone ever. I don't care about the politics, I don't care about the name, I just don't think it should be FSE's word that says all and ends all, when it honestly has nothing to do with them.

My two cents, rage all you want.

[CHARLES111MAC]

I just wanted to see what people think as the FSE word is final

More than likly this will be locked soon ...

[Odysseus]

Well I don't see a lock, since we are discussing this civily and respectfully towards each other and fse.

The one thing I find bad is that the mods choose what regiments are retired. The community should have a say, at least in what regiments are retired.

[CHARLES111MAC]

This is not to moan this is to see if people find it fair that a name they could want to be is denied and how long till alot of names are up there ?

[Odysseus]

As previously stated, the community should decide which regiments should be retired, not the ones the admins liked most. I would like to here an admin post here.

[CHARLES111MAC]

I would like more people to give their views

[Odysseus]

I would like more people to give their views

Most of the Europeans are offline at this point. 

[Deofuta]

FSE will remain firm in this decision. Like I said in our many PMs together, it was not a matter of punishing anyone, and it was unfortunate that it ever was up for the taking. I would advise those who are angry with this decision to focus on moving forward, and working on regiments that could down the road also be considered for such an endeavor. There are many, many regiments that still have yet to be used.