Author Topic: Russian plane shot down by Turkey  (Read 20991 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline BabyJesus

  • General
  • ****
  • Posts: 12200
  • #1 Cringe poster and lover of Anna Kendrick
    • View Profile
  • Nick: Most Average MVP of All Time
  • Side: Union
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #90 on: November 25, 2015, 01:46:10 pm »
Spoiler
[close]
1st NWPC S2(21st)|(1st) 5v5 Draft~NA GroupFighting Tournament  |1st♕Rex's 6v6 Tournament | 1st TNWL S2(71st) | 1st NWL S5 (58e) | 3rd place Sleeks 5v5 (Highschoole DxD)
You are by far the best average player to touch this game.
Quote from: Risk
The BEST average player of all time

Offline Ted

  • Colonel
  • *
  • Posts: 4478
  • Aufknöpfen!
    • View Profile
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #91 on: November 25, 2015, 02:10:35 pm »
Turkey is obviously lying. Sukhoi 24 can fly at 2300 kilometres per hour, which means that they could cross those 3 kilometres in a few seconds. For them to cross it in 17 seconds, they would have had to fly roughly around 700km/h. Why would they do that considering that they were allegedly warned by Turkey?

According to the document sent to the UN by Turkey, they crossed even less than 3 kilometers, so flight speed would have been even slower.

Moreover, if they started warning 5 minutes BEFORE they crossed the border:
- SU 24 were still far from the border.
- They couldn't predict their intentions.



If you had looked at the radar you would have notice that the Su24 had been flying directly towards the turkish border for a few minutes so the warnings were right. And if you had studied at least a bit about warfare you would have noticed that you don't fly on maximumspeed during combat. You also ask why they would do that after being warned. If they really got the warning and still flew through turkish airspace Turkey had every right to shoot them down, the speed of the jet does not affect this right.

Turkey had warned to shoot down any foreign military aircraft on their territory on October 8th. It is common practice to warn military vehicles even before they reach the border to give them enough time to turn around.

Fact is for now:

The Russian jet entered turkish airspace even after being warned several times.
Two Turkish F16s shot down the Jet which then crashed on syrian territory. It is unclear where exactly the shots werefired.
One Russian pilot is dead, the other's location is unclear.
1. Your remark regarding speed is a sophism. You don't fly at low speed either, and certainly not under such circumstances. Please tell me the exact speed of a sukhoi su 24 crossing this small band of territory in 17 seconds.
2. Please tell us the distance and fly time between the Russian airbase and the Turkish border. Also tell us when exactly they should have warned the plane and we will study your assertion with proper data.
3. You are too young to compare your level of studies to mine. I suggest that you keep you refrain from ad hominem attacks.

Ok I've just finished lunch and got my maths right. According to this radar
Spoiler
[close]

and after having checked two maps for reference you can say that the jet crossed approximateley 3.5 to 4km of turkish airspace. In order to cross this territory, the Su24 had to fly 3500/17*3.6 = 741km/h (4000/17*3.6 = 847 km/h if you take the 4km or 526.3 MPH for the more US based persons here). The highest speed possible for a Suchoi Su24 is Mach 2,18.

Not calculated into this is a possible climb that may have been performed by the pilots, requiring a faster speed in order to cross this 3.5 to 4km in 17 seconds.

I honestly don't know from which airbase the aircraft started, how long it took the jet to aquire it's needed heigth and how long the whole mission had taken until that time. It still is common practice to warn military aircrafts at least 5-6min before they reach the border, giving them time to turn around. There still needs to be a quite large timeframe in order to have enough time to get the two F16s in the air, what normally is initiated when the first warning is spoken. Give me some time to calculate the time it took the jet to reach the border.

I will still need some time to figure a Su24's stall speed out, but you are able to fly easily with 741 - 847 km/h (A normal, much heavier plane like the Boeing 747-300 flies at 910km/h travelspeed with 377.000 kg! A Su24 only has 36.000 kg!!!). It also is more comfortable for the pilot to stay under Mach 1,0 as the body is not pressed into the seat then. And yes, aircrafts usually do not fly on highest speed when fighting groundtargets as you don't have enough time to use your weapons properly against groundtargets when on fullspeed and also are heavily pressed into your seat when on fullspeed.



PS: The one not providing any necessary proof for his assertion is you; please refrain from posting before having calculated anything, thanks.


« Last Edit: November 25, 2015, 05:19:35 pm by Ted »
Dat kid who put up a global banlist back in Betty's times.
Former Regiments: 7te Kurmarkische Landwehr, 6te Ulanen, kk Kürassierregiment Nr.4, kk Bombardier-Regiment Nr.3, kk AR Nr.2, GGR Nr.4, Artillerie im Kö.Preuß.IR Nr.33.
>>Scenes<<

Offline Dazzer

  • Donator
  • *
  • Posts: 5690
    • View Profile
  • Side: Union
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #92 on: November 25, 2015, 06:37:36 pm »
Spoiler
Turkey is obviously lying. Sukhoi 24 can fly at 2300 kilometres per hour, which means that they could cross those 3 kilometres in a few seconds. For them to cross it in 17 seconds, they would have had to fly roughly around 700km/h. Why would they do that considering that they were allegedly warned by Turkey?

According to the document sent to the UN by Turkey, they crossed even less than 3 kilometers, so flight speed would have been even slower.

Moreover, if they started warning 5 minutes BEFORE they crossed the border:
- SU 24 were still far from the border.
- They couldn't predict their intentions.



If you had looked at the radar you would have notice that the Su24 had been flying directly towards the turkish border for a few minutes so the warnings were right. And if you had studied at least a bit about warfare you would have noticed that you don't fly on maximumspeed during combat. You also ask why they would do that after being warned. If they really got the warning and still flew through turkish airspace Turkey had every right to shoot them down, the speed of the jet does not affect this right.

Turkey had warned to shoot down any foreign military aircraft on their territory on October 8th. It is common practice to warn military vehicles even before they reach the border to give them enough time to turn around.

Fact is for now:

The Russian jet entered turkish airspace even after being warned several times.
Two Turkish F16s shot down the Jet which then crashed on syrian territory. It is unclear where exactly the shots werefired.
One Russian pilot is dead, the other's location is unclear.
1. Your remark regarding speed is a sophism. You don't fly at low speed either, and certainly not under such circumstances. Please tell me the exact speed of a sukhoi su 24 crossing this small band of territory in 17 seconds.
2. Please tell us the distance and fly time between the Russian airbase and the Turkish border. Also tell us when exactly they should have warned the plane and we will study your assertion with proper data.
3. You are too young to compare your level of studies to mine. I suggest that you keep you refrain from ad hominem attacks.

Ok I've just finished lunch and got my maths right. According to this radar
Spoiler
[close]

and after having checked two maps for reference you can say that the jet crossed approximateley 3.5 to 4km of turkish airspace. In order to cross this territory, the Su24 had to fly 3500/17*3.6 = 741km/h (4000/17*3.6 = 847 km/h if you take the 4km or 526.3 MPH for the more US based persons here). The highest speed possible for a Suchoi Su24 is Mach 2,18.

Not calculated into this is a possible climb that may have been performed by the pilots, requiring a faster speed in order to cross this 3.5 to 4km in 17 seconds.

I honestly don't know from which airbase the aircraft started, how long it took the jet to aquire it's needed heigth and how long the whole mission had taken until that time. It still is common practice to warn military aircrafts at least 5-6min before they reach the border, giving them time to turn around. There still needs to be a quite large timeframe in order to have enough time to get the two F16s in the air, what normally is initiated when the first warning is spoken. Give me some time to calculate the time it took the jet to reach the border.

I will still need some time to figure a Su24's stall speed out, but you are able to fly easily with 741 - 847 km/h (A normal, much heavier plane like the Boeing 747-300 flies at 910km/h travelspeed with 377.000 kg! A Su24 only has 36.000 kg!!!). It also is more comfortable for the pilot to stay under Mach 1,0 as the body is not pressed into the seat then. And yes, aircrafts usually do not fly on highest speed when fighting groundtargets as you don't have enough time to use your weapons properly against groundtargets when on fullspeed and also are heavily pressed into your seat when on fullspeed.



PS: The one not providing any necessary proof for his assertion is you; please refrain from posting before having calculated anything, thanks.po
[close]
so we have to calculate everything?  :P

Offline Dazzer

  • Donator
  • *
  • Posts: 5690
    • View Profile
  • Side: Union
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #93 on: November 25, 2015, 07:16:26 pm »
Coalition of devils...

Offline Liam

  • Major General
  • **
  • Posts: 2293
  • Liam innit
    • View Profile
  • Nick: Liam
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #94 on: November 25, 2015, 07:47:55 pm »
Ted's math hurt my head I forgot that * meant x lmao

Offline DaMonkey

  • King of FSE
  • *
  • Posts: 1677
    • View Profile
  • Nick: King DaMonkey I
  • Side: Confederacy
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #95 on: November 25, 2015, 10:50:22 pm »
Spoiler
[close]

Why in Gods name would Russia arm the Kurds?

Because it would be the biggest thing to act against Turkey short of actually attacking them, proxy wars are the classic Major Power move.

Spoiler
[close]


Glad you posted the exact same image from a few posts earlier.





How do you violate airspace 2,000 in one year?
Did you know that if you use 100% of your brain, you get godlike powers? true story.
Did you know that if you use 10% of received donations, you can release BCoF by now. true story

Offline Duuring

  • Duuring
  • ***
  • Posts: 12357
  • Free at last
    • View Profile
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #96 on: November 25, 2015, 10:52:20 pm »
Spoiler
[close]

Why in Gods name would Russia arm the Kurds?

Because it would be the biggest thing to act against Turkey short of actually attacking them, proxy wars are the classic Major Power move.

Yeah, sadly the Syrian Kurds are also fighting against Assad, together with the opposition.

Offline Grantrithor

  • Second Lieutenant
  • *
  • Posts: 915
  • <><><><>
    • View Profile
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #97 on: November 25, 2015, 11:31:11 pm »
Ted's math hurt my head I forgot that * meant x lmao

his math was literally 3 operations.

Offline Danik

  • First Lieutenant
  • *
  • Posts: 292
  • Better than Justin Bieber since 1960
    • View Profile
  • Side: Confederacy
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #98 on: November 26, 2015, 02:39:57 am »
Currently, Kurds and Russian forces are fighting in different parts of Syria. Multiple news sources tells that a major leader from Peshmerga forces have shown interest in closer co-operation with Russia.

Offline Malkolm R. Lind

  • Major
  • *
  • Posts: 1591
  • Why do drugs when you can listen to music?
    • View Profile
  • Nick: Illya
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #99 on: November 26, 2015, 07:07:45 am »
Trust me. Just Turkey tryin' to be a part of the cool kids. :P

Offline MaxLam

  • Colonel
  • *
  • Posts: 1343
  • Founder of Minisiege, EU_Commander & Mininaval
    • View Profile
    • Napoleonic Wars Public
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #100 on: November 26, 2015, 10:59:46 am »

Quote
and after having checked two maps for reference you can say that the jet crossed approximateley 3.5 to 4km of turkish airspace. In order to cross this territory, the Su24 had to fly 3500/17*3.6 = 741km/h (4000/17*3.6 = 847 km/h if you take the 4km or 526.3 MPH for the more US based persons here). The highest speed possible for a Suchoi Su24 is Mach 2,18.

Not calculated into this is a possible climb that may have been performed by the pilots, requiring a faster speed in order to cross this 3.5 to 4km in 17 seconds.

I honestly don't know from which airbase the aircraft started, how long it took the jet to aquire it's needed heigth and how long the whole mission had taken until that time. It still is common practice to warn military aircrafts at least 5-6min before they reach the border, giving them time to turn around. There still needs to be a quite large timeframe in order to have enough time to get the two F16s in the air, what normally is initiated when the first warning is spoken. Give me some time to calculate the time it took the jet to reach the border.

I will still need some time to figure a Su24's stall speed out, but you are able to fly easily with 741 - 847 km/h (A normal, much heavier plane like the Boeing 747-300 flies at 910km/h travelspeed with 377.000 kg! A Su24 only has 36.000 kg!!!). It also is more comfortable for the pilot to stay under Mach 1,0 as the body is not pressed into the seat then. And yes, aircrafts usually do not fly on highest speed when fighting groundtargets as you don't have enough time to use your weapons properly against groundtargets when on fullspeed and also are heavily pressed into your seat when on fullspeed.



PS: The one not providing any necessary proof for his assertion is you; please refrain from posting before having calculated anything, thanks.
1. You didn't provided any more "proof" than I did. And I must stress that the media provided all the necessary evidences, including those that you dismissed.
2. Amongst those evidences, you dismissed half of Turkey's letter to NATO, which says that the plane stayed for 17 seconds in their airspace but also admits that it represented "1.15 miles in lenght", which is 1.6 kilometers and not 3-4 as you said. The result is a speed of 338.8212km/h, which is less than HALF of your own result, and this is a complete nonsense.
3. According to the radar picture provided by Turkey (but probably made on Paint), the plane which was shot turned in the direction of Turkish territory a maximum of 1.5 minutes before it was downed. Now if they had warned the pilots 5 minutes before, it means that they warned them as they were flying SOUTH/SOUTH-EAST.



4. Finally, the location of the Russian airbase that you couldn't provide is well-known. It's the Khmeimim air base at Latakia. It's located less than 50 kilometers South-West from this part of the Turkish border. Which means that all Russian planes going North would need to get warned by Turkey as they would need less than 5 minutes to go there (5 minutes at 600km/h). Moreover, ALL RUSSIAN PLANES IN THIS AREA, turning North even for a moment, would have to get warned.

This is, once again, the evidence that Turkey is completely lying and that they never warned the pilots.

Offline Duuring

  • Duuring
  • ***
  • Posts: 12357
  • Free at last
    • View Profile
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #101 on: November 26, 2015, 11:17:02 am »
Currently, Kurds and Russian forces are fighting in different parts of Syria. Multiple news sources tells that a major leader from Peshmerga forces have shown interest in closer co-operation with Russia.

Peshmerga are Iraqi Kurds.

Offline Rejenorst

  • Lieutenant Colonel
  • *
  • Posts: 2348
    • View Profile
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #102 on: November 26, 2015, 12:20:34 pm »
Turkey is obviously lying. Sukhoi 24 can fly at 2300 kilometres per hour, which means that they could cross those 3 kilometres in a few seconds. For them to cross it in 17 seconds, they would have had to fly roughly around 700km/h. Why would they do that considering that they were allegedly warned by Turkey?

According to the document sent to the UN by Turkey, they crossed even less than 3 kilometers, so flight speed would have been even slower.

Moreover, if they started warning 5 minutes BEFORE they crossed the border:
- SU 24 were still far from the border.
- They couldn't predict their intentions.

I came into this thread very late so I apologize if I am repeating same old same old.

Max speed of an SU24 is 1,315 km/h or 1,550km/h afaik.
http://www.airforce-technology.com/projects/su24/su245.html

It may be able to endure/attain higher speeds on a dive though.

700km/h is probably not unrealistic at lower altitudes. The 1,315 km/h would most likely only be maintained at cruising altitude.


Turkey claims that the Russian jet flew 1.36 miles (2.19 kilometers) into Turkish airspace. So at 17 seconds that would be apprx: 463km/h.
http://www.i24news.tv/en/news/international/93513-151125-us-believes-russian-jet-exploded-in-syrian-airspace-official
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-11-24/17-seconds-changed-world-leaked-letter-exposes-turkeys-hair-trigger-reality

17 seconds of airspace violation is not the only reason the plane was shot down. As Erdogan himself stated:

The Turkish president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, said on Wednesday that the Russian jet was in Turkish airspace when it was shot down and parts of the wreckage had fallen into Turkey, injuring two people. Ankara had no wish to escalate the incident and was only defending “our own security and the rights of our brothers” in Syria , he added.


Turkey supports the Turkmen and Russia is bombing them. Problem is it's accused of supporting more than just so called moderates:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-l-phillips/research-paper-isis-turke_b_6128950.html?ir=Australia
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/nov/18/turkey-cut-islamic-state-supply-lines-erdogan-isis
http://www.businessinsider.com.au/links-between-turkey-and-isis-are-now-undeniable-2015-7?r=US&IR=T

At the end of the day even if the Russian plane entered Turkish airspace; it was shot down over Syrian airspace and quite possibly targeted over Syrian airspace as well after it had exited said Airspace. Russia's response is to increase its AA capability with escorts and ground/Sea AA. This  means that every time a Turkish jet now comes close to the Russian/Syrian air border operations Russia will have to decide whether or not it is hostile, poses a threat and whether or not it needs to be eliminated.

Not a good situation to have both sides treat each other as potentially hostile targets.
« Last Edit: November 26, 2015, 12:43:09 pm by Rejenorst »
Spoiler

[close]

Offline MaxLam

  • Colonel
  • *
  • Posts: 1343
  • Founder of Minisiege, EU_Commander & Mininaval
    • View Profile
    • Napoleonic Wars Public
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #103 on: November 26, 2015, 01:00:46 pm »
I would dismiss your point regarding altitude for 3 reasons:
- Russia said that the altitude was 6000 meters, which is a high altitude (in comparison MH17 was flying at 5200m).
- Videos tend to confirm this.
- Flying at 700km/h at low altitude is stupid as you can become an easy target for AA weapons, including manpads, and rebels have some, especially in this area as they are equipped by US. As you can imagine, flying at 338km/h as I said above is complete suicide.
« Last Edit: November 26, 2015, 01:07:39 pm by MaxLam »

Offline Rejenorst

  • Lieutenant Colonel
  • *
  • Posts: 2348
    • View Profile
  • Side: Neutral
Re: Russian plane shot down by Turkey
« Reply #104 on: November 26, 2015, 01:07:26 pm »
6km is out of range for small arms and AA MGs like the ZU-23 which has an effective range of 2-2.5km
Thus far rebels are not known to be using manpads afaik. If the U.S. is smart it wouldn't distribute weapons that could be used against its own air-force or that of its allies.

Flying at lower speeds may be required as a bomber if your attempting to paint targets or find targets.

Also I am not saying it was flying at apprx 700km/h. I have no idea how fast it was flying but I am saying that it can easily fly at that speed without stalling. As a bomber doing a bombing run against rebel targets and at lower altitudes its likely not going at max speed.

Cruise alt is at 10km >

« Last Edit: November 26, 2015, 01:10:12 pm by Rejenorst »
Spoiler

[close]