I like Orcaryo, Dan, and Pickle as people. Don't think they would be the CRs we need though.
Orcaryo, has not done a whole lot as the CR to be honest. I think previous CRs have completed more in one term (Which was the precedent set for NA CRs, which Orcaryo broke, worth noting) than Orcaryo has really completed in both his terms. To be fair with him though, NA is rather dead at the moment. Far more dead than it has been at any point. The worst thing that can happen in the community right now is for nothing to change, for the status quo to continue. However, there is opportunity here.
While Dan and Pickle are merely speculation on my part as to not being the CR we need, and I am more than willing to give them a chance. So, why do I say Dan and Pickle aren't the CRs we need? I just simply think that they would not do much to bring anything fresh to the community or the position of CR. They are just two more people that fit the mold of someone who has been playing NW for a while and are just decently popular in the community. Maybe they will be good CRs, maybe they won't, but I feel if I had to take a chance on someone here, I would take a chance on the person who least fits the norm for who has been NA CRs thus far.
That person would be Gluk. He is not someone in the upper echelons of the NA community, who has been playing for years and years and accumulated 1000s of hours like all the other CRs/Applicants. To me, he has always seemed to want to serve a community oriented role, and I think that is what we need right now. I think his somewhat outsider perspective could well bring something fresh to the role, something we desperately need.