Suggestions and feedback [v1.0 - v1.1]

[KillerShark]

If the bleeding system is being kept can there be an indication that lets you know you are bleeding?

[Arkansan]

lol the spurting blood isn't enough?

[KillerShark]

It's sometimes hard to tell. In Iron Europe I'm pretty sure they put an icon to let you know.

[Kacper.]

My suggestion is add this: http://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php?topic=121815.0

[ThePatriot98]

My suggestion is add this: http://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php?topic=121815.0

good idea

[Dazzer]

I know Illinois wasn't attendet to Bull Run much, but I would like to see them In game

[vtz]

Hey,
I've got 2 things to say,
First, I guess it would be nice to have both bandage and some sort of "surgery kit" It would only be available to medic and would make you regain portion of your health points. Medic class wouldn't be useless anymore, and think about it - you are hit by a bullet. You fall, but someone takes you back, takes the bullet off and puts a bandage. Would it make you way more likely to die from another bullet? I don't think so. This medical item should surely be veeery slow, to express time needed for simple surgery.
Second, I support the idea of adding sword bayonet for Mississippi, even if it will be slow and pretty useless, it would remove the bottle bug. If you're unable to remove this bug other way, of course.

[hairywarhero]

Hey,
I've got 2 things to say,
First, I guess it would be nice to have both bandage and some sort of "surgery kit" It would only be available to medic and would make you regain portion of your health points. Medic class wouldn't be useless anymore, and think about it - you are hit by a bullet. You fall, but someone takes you back, takes the bullet off and puts a bandage. Would it make you way more likely to die from another bullet? I don't think so. This medical item should surely be veeery slow, to express time needed for simple surgery.
Second, I support the idea of adding sword bayonet for Mississippi, even if it will be slow and pretty useless, it would remove the bottle bug. If you're unable to remove this bug other way, of course.

the surgery kit bad idea it would cause more camping and longer rounds

[Hinkel]

Hey,
I've got 2 things to say,
First, I guess it would be nice to have both bandage and some sort of "surgery kit" It would only be available to medic and would make you regain portion of your health points. Medic class wouldn't be useless anymore, and think about it - you are hit by a bullet. You fall, but someone takes you back, takes the bullet off and puts a bandage. Would it make you way more likely to die from another bullet? I don't think so. This medical item should surely be veeery slow, to express time needed for simple surgery.
Second, I support the idea of adding sword bayonet for Mississippi, even if it will be slow and pretty useless, it would remove the bottle bug. If you're unable to remove this bug other way, of course.

The wounded system was added to make the rounds faster. If you could get healed, it would become a camp party, like Hairy said.
Also, the mississippi is a skirmish rifle, thats why it has no bayonet. Same for the Lorenz rifle...

The bottle bug will be fixed.

[vtz]

Ok, good to know.
I'd also like to say that Maryland's and North Carolina's II privates seem to have better accuracy, which is ... Is this intended?
And I would also have a request about uniforms, could you make them slightly dirtier and less straight? So that they would look more like a used uniform and less like an ironed suit?

[Hinkel]

Ok, good to know.
I'd also like to say that Maryland's and North Carolina's II privates seem to have better accuracy, which is ... Is this intended?
And I would also have a request about uniforms, could you make them slightly dirtier and less straight? So that they would look more like a used uniform and less like an ironed suit?

Private II for most units is the skirmisher/light infantry, which has better accuracy, but less melee stats.
The uniforms are straight, cause Manassas was the first battle of the war.

The mod is not about the entire civil war, its about the first battle of Manassas. Thats why the uniforms have less dirt

[vtz]

Private II for most units is the skirmisher/light infantry, which has better accuracy, but less melee stats.
The uniforms are straight, cause Manassas was the first battle of the war.

Aaah, it makes sense so much now xD I though II private is only supposed to have his rank on shoulder

The mod is not about the entire civil war, its about the first battle of Manassas. Thats why the uniforms have less dirt

Waiting for North & South: Third Petersburg then   
But to be serious, whith all these things discussed I can only wait for new units and a small thing I though off today: I think it would be a good idea to modify map names. Bigger ones used for line battles could have (big) in its name and smaller ones would have (small) That would surely help to chose a good map for people who want to play with random guys but don't know which map to chose. I often play with 8 guys on Manassas map and it's quite bad to march all the way to them

[vtz]

Well actually... I've got some things to tell yet :p

I wish rifles / muskets were more accurate and took more time to reload. And also it'd be great if springfield was useful. I always wanted to be line infantry but both UA and DA are spammed with sharpshooters and skirmishers, what makes LI gameplay a series of being shot every round, without even getting a chance to use your bayonet.

What sounds as nothing special but could possibly change the mod a lot is making soldiers actually march, not run when moving. It would really add much immersion in my opinion. Also, it'd be great if soldiers were mostly marching, but get the possibility to run when very close to the enemy (charging).

And finally, I've seen your previous mod - Secession. It had something like morale system, which sounds really interesting. Why was it removed? Was it buggy? Or maybe players didn't like it?

Thank you

[hairywarhero]

I don't think you've been to a UA lb haha we use nearly enough the same tactics as in NW when it comes down to rules plus we only allow 1 sharpshooter and no skrims. Maybe come along to a event and see for your self we do have big brawl out in melee

[Hinkel]

Well actually... I've got some things to tell yet :p

I wish rifles / muskets were more accurate and took more time to reload. And also it'd be great if springfield was useful. I always wanted to be line infantry but both UA and DA are spammed with sharpshooters and skirmishers, what makes LI gameplay a series of being shot every round, without even getting a chance to use your bayonet.

What sounds as nothing special but could possibly change the mod a lot is making soldiers actually march, not run when moving. It would really add much immersion in my opinion. Also, it'd be great if soldiers were mostly marching, but get the possibility to run when very close to the enemy (charging).

And finally, I've seen your previous mod - Secession. It had something like morale system, which sounds really interesting. Why was it removed? Was it buggy? Or maybe players didn't like it?

Thank you

1) The mod is made for line battles only. A round needs between 15-20 minutes at the moment. If the reload would be longer, we would have insane round times

2) Running as default is needed. If there would be a stamina system, it would be different. But this is not planned

3) Secession is a different mod. We could add morale, but it would have to much impact on the line battles.

There is a reason, why this mod stays more for arcade and fast gameplay. There are games in development, which are based more on realism like you want