I will only cover albums made at the height of their fame, primarily because most of the post The Black Album songs were either average or garbage.
Unmatched
1. One
2. Fade to Black
3. Master of Puppets
4. Creeping Death
5. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
6. Battery
7. Ride The Lightning
8. Seek and Destroy
9. For Whom the Bell Tolls
10. Enter Sandman
Legendary
11. The Unforgiven
12. The Four Horsemen
13. Sad But True
14. ...And Justice for All
15. Orion
16. Whiplash
17. Disposable Heroes
18. Blackened
19. Nothing Else Matters
20. Wherever I May Roam
Good
21. Hit the Lights
22. The Call of Ktulu
23. Escape
24. To Live Is To Die
25. Fight Fire With Fire
26. Trapped Under Ice
27. Leper Messiah
28. My Friend of Misery
29. Damage Inc.
30. Harvester of Sorrow
Average
31. The Thing That Should Not Be
32. Metal Militia
33. The Shortest Straw
34. The Frayed Ends of Sanity
35. Jump in the Fire
36. Anesthesia-Pulling Teeth
37. Dyers Eve
38. Don't Tread on Me
39. Holier Than Thou
40. Eye Of The Beholder
Meh
41. The God That Failed
42. Through the Never
43. Phantom Lord
44. The Struggle Within
45. No Remorse
46. Motorbreath
47. Of Wolf and Man