North American Melee & Regiment Hall of Fame

[BabyJesus]

can’t wrap my head around jaax and cwater being in t2 but other than that looks good nephew

cant wrap my head around that cwater cheats, never seen much of jaax heard hes quite good. But what was jaax doing in 2015-2016 when the game was at its peak?

also the update ruined the game catering to skeyers and boring meleers like cwater godfreid etc...

why does it matter when the game peaked?

you mean back when there wasn't only 20 competitive players? That's one reason lol

Ig 80 players for James's league and 72 players for Risk's league = 20 players

still nothing compared to what it use to be

Cool. 500 bots vs 80 people that know how to block

I usually dont agree with Bill but. To be fair it wasnt 500 bots then and if all 80 people knew how to block now your Jedis team wouldve made the finals.... instead of jaax killing himself to drop over 40 kills a map and you guys still losing because you couldnt block.

if we were going up against old gens we all would have got 40 kills

[Wastee]

My hot takes

Tier 1 Changes

- Godfreid, Bill, Ap0c, Ritz, Havoc (No disrespect to any of these players I just don't think they matchup quite with the other tier 1 players and fall more along the lines of the current tier 2 players, Godfreid is super close due to the longterm duel dominance and regimental impacts)

Tier 2 Changes

- Alexander, Breaches, Colonys, Kovy, Mang, Zorkoth, NickCole, Puppytron, Rafael

+ Vortex

Tier 3

+ Horse, PJ, Karth (Not even on list??), Krastinov

Tier 4

- Boob, Dragonpuff, Mitchell, Gamechanger, PsychoTwinz (which one tho), Scopes

+ BabyJesus, Risk, Ser Wall, Pedro, Red Viper, Gavin (Not even on list??), ghostrider (not on list???)

Other people not on it I think that should be somewhere, probably tier 4/5

James, Tico, Vertildr, Fartknocker, Jorge, Ryner/Lucifer, Blade, Armada, Red Wall, Dodge, Ritz407, Hunter, Stryker

Sorry if I missed someone or someone was there and I said they weren't

Helpful sources to go along with my opinions

Tournament Wins per Person - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1GhNLuzYxqw4z9t3r5Q8UbLNHOW_2O6qRkKR_XYgnhbQ/edit#gid=0

Combined All draft leagues leaderboards -
 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ftJ6jvoO9BZA4I6sSZJFRdWJoaj4R6aDgv23ZkIDilw/edit#gid=1172207476

Tournament Archive - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1gTZ-ZmnQgA8wAW3zVNlpS-2ZN-rC382Zod9n29M5u6Y/edit


* another note I can probably clarify on more when I’m home but differentiating the top 3 tiers

1- always dominant or very good, staples of the melee community
2- top player for extended time, very good for a long time - broke the glass
3- almost broke the glass but fell short, periods of being good but also periods of being avg/below avg. or not enough time played to warrant quite yet (horse has broken the glass and soon would be considered tier 2)

[Moraine]

can’t wrap my head around jaax and cwater being in t2 but other than that looks good nephew

cant wrap my head around that cwater cheats, never seen much of jaax heard hes quite good. But what was jaax doing in 2015-2016 when the game was at its peak?

also the update ruined the game catering to skeyers and boring meleers like cwater godfreid etc...

that is a pub admin btw

Hey! I also admined comp to!

[|Viper|]

Update!

^ PJ moved up from tier 4 to tier 3
^ SerWall moved up from tier 5 to tier 4
^ Krastinov moved up from tier 4 to tier 3
+ Tico added to tier 4
+ Karth added to tier 4
+ Blade added to tier 4
+ Ghostrider7811 added to tier 4

- B00B lowered from tier 4 to tier 5
- Maccle lowered from tier 3 to tier 4
- Zorkoth lowered from tier 2 to tier 3
- Breaches lowered from tier 2 to tier 3
- Colonys22 lowered from tier 2 to tier 3
- Gamechanger lowered from tier 4 to tier 5
- WorstNANickCole lowered from tier 2 to tier 3

This isn't the final update but I'm not going to do it all in one night.

[Phil The Thril]

can’t wrap my head around jaax and cwater being in t2 but other than that looks good nephew

cant wrap my head around that cwater cheats, never seen much of jaax heard hes quite good. But what was jaax doing in 2015-2016 when the game was at its peak?

also the update ruined the game catering to skeyers and boring meleers like cwater godfreid etc...

/thread

The King has spoken

[Yvrul]

This has got to be one of the worst tier list ever. Gamechanger #1

[MikeyBruh]

Damn wastee it’s like that

[KillerShark]

Whoever thinks Karth should be on a melee list just needs to get a reality check. At no point in his career was he even average at melee

[MikeyBruh]

Whoever thinks Karth should be on a melee list just needs to get a reality check. At no point in his career was he even average at melee

Movement key moment
it’s melee and regimental so I think him leading the 63e elevates him a lot

[|Viper|]

Whoever thinks Karth should be on a melee list just needs to get a reality check. At no point in his career was he even average at melee

Movement key moment
it’s melee and regimental so I think him leading the 63e elevates him a lot

^ This

Karth actually has a decent amount of placements too, although he wasn't "the man" on the field by any means (unless there was a hill on the map) he does fit the tier 4 (MAX) criteria. I'll post the criteria again in case some people missed my previous post about it.

Karth has the longevity because his reign of winning started from 2013 and stopped in 2015, regimental impact I'm sure he had some what of an influence on because it's the 63e. He placed in 7 tournaments (beating Bill or Mang in one duel tournament?), and Karth was a two way player, but max he's getting is tier 4.

- Longevity/consistency (how long you were a top/good/decent player… NOT how long you’ve been playing)
- Regimental impact (top 5 player/melee impact)
- Tournaments & leagues impact (wins/losses)
- Two or one way player

[Hawkince]

can’t wrap my head around jaax and cwater being in t2 but other than that looks good nephew

cant wrap my head around that cwater cheats, never seen much of jaax heard hes quite good. But what was jaax doing in 2015-2016 when the game was at its peak?

also the update ruined the game catering to skeyers and boring meleers like cwater godfreid etc...

that is a pub admin btw

I play the game once in a blue moon nowadays, When I was active and the game was actually ACTIVE AS WELL AND NOT dead. I had a 3.5 kd and noone else broke 2.5 kd while i was at top of the leaderboards lol...and not on broken melee broken script heavy servers you bums play on now

[MikeyBruh]

I think bill needs his own tier or lowe every other t1 to t2

[Wastee]

I always remembered Karth being above average, held his own in the gfing tournaments 63e logic won and placed in.

Fireboy could probably vouch or bash more

[fireboy]

I always remembered Karth being above average, held his own in the gfing tournaments 63e logic won and placed in.

Fireboy could probably vouch or bash more

Yeah karth was on a couple of my chicken mastas teams that won tournies

[KillerShark]

I guess all of these are just based off of random tournaments as opposed to actual skill though. This list would be entirely different with actual skill factored in