It may have been valid if grimsight used the old 3e group. For the others you mentioned, EU doesn't count and the others have not shown up like ever. BabyG will be told to leave his groups as well as Ema. The big problem was that Chantakey requested a transfer of an 18th member, which is an active regiment and participant in TNWL. A person who is known for double regging/hopping and is still in the 18th group. It was not even posted by carribou himself, so how do we know he left the 18th?