I can't remember if I have fought you or not
However you do post on this thread a lot which suggests either you are really good and you like people knowing about it, or you could be really quite bad and are desperate to see if anyone thinks you have improved recently. That being said others seem to believe you are rather quite good, or at least better than me anyway.
Therefore after a long and now come to think of it pretty stupid analysis, I have come to the conclusion that your melee skill is somewhere around the 8.5/10 mark.