Spoiler
As you seem not able to find any sort of common ground and I dont really have a strong stand on this matter, I'm going to let you guys decide what we're going to do. I want the RGL to be interactive so I'll let you decide what the rule is gonna be on this as I see good arguments on both sides. The poll will end in 5 days. The voters will not be shown so you're free to vote whatever you want and no one can check whether you stick to your word or not. The option that has the most votes will be applied.
Please spoiler huge paragraphs if quoiting them in the future and try not to post too much off topic.
Thanks to those who have argued with us and/or will participate in the poll.
Could you explain the reasoning for making a public vote, implying people who won't partake into the RGL to give their opinion? The best way to do it if you intend to make people vote is to open applications for everyone, and once they're closed, you ask the regimental leaders their vote and take a decision based on such votes before the tournament starts. Regiment leader representing the interest of their regiments and members, that way you have the opinions of everyone who is going to play in the RGL and therefore, the
opinions which matter are all taken into account.