♞ Cavalry Napoleonic Wars League - Season 1-3

[Pilophas]

I don't see any reason for putting pressure on the teams by putting a time limit on them.

First it would require a lot of extra rules (What for example happens when time is up and both teams have the same number of people still living?), of explanation and will result in a very discutable rule i'm sure not everyone will be happy with.

Second a time limit would limit a regiments tactical options. Head on charge would be the only solution sometimes and that's not what i call a fight on pro-level.

There for sure are a lot more reasons not to add this rule, but these two arguments should actually already be enough.

[Celtic_Jan]

Second a time limit would limit a regiments tactical options. Head on charge would be the only solution sometimes and that's not what i call a fight on pro-level.

Oh you mean that "pro-leavel" is running for 15 mins, then fighting 2 mins and again running for 100 mins?

[Lilja Mariasdóttir]

I think a timelimit wouldnt help at all.
It is right, nobody likes it, when the enemy is more running than fighting.
But keep in mind, if this case happens, referee can put pressure on the team which is delaying.
And we got this season no complaints about regiments that delay extremly. So we dont think a timelimit is necessary.


The discussion about the swordpicking seems to be over, sadly no one of the guys, which brought the rule in in the first place, brought arguments for it.
I will now add a voting about the rule, but I think it will be clear against the rule^^
Keep in mind, that the voting is not binding, as we have no control about who is voting, it is just a addition to our opinion-making.

[Okra]

vote for allow or forbid picking swords guys

[Zahari]

picking up swords should be allowed... pls it is part of this game

Second a time limit would limit a regiments tactical options. Head on charge would be the only solution sometimes and that's not what i call a fight on pro-level.

Oh you mean that "pro-leavel" is running for 15 mins, then fighting 2 mins and again running for 100 mins?

It is good idea because if reg X will run away for 15-30 mins than reg Y will win this round

[Celtic_Jan]

But keep in mind, if this case happens, referee can put pressure on the team which is delaying.

Sounds good.

[Celtic_Jan]

picking up swords should be allowed... pls it is part of this game

+1, Allow this for gods sake, some realism should be in.

[Martastik]

Please no time-limit, that is the most cancerous idea i've ever heard.

Imagine the situation where it's 1 player of each team left, and they're both really good players. It's the last round and the one who wins will define the winner of the match.

Do you really want to put pressure on that, limit their time? Maybe even let it run out to 0 while they're both still alive, creating a draw? Come on....

[Rival]

Time limits great. I dont know what you're talking about

Spoiler

[close]

[Celtic_Jan]

Please no time-limit, that is the most cancerous idea i've ever heard.

Imagine the situation where it's 1 player of each team left, and they're both really good players. It's the last round and the one who wins will define the winner of the match.

Do you really want to put pressure on that, limit their time? Maybe even let it run out to 0 while they're both still alive, creating a draw? Come on....

Situation 1v1 - referee might increase time, if is it needed to make a duel?

[Zahari]

Please no time-limit, that is the most cancerous idea i've ever heard.

Imagine the situation where it's 1 player of each team left, and they're both really good players. It's the last round and the one who wins will define the winner of the match.

Do you really want to put pressure on that, limit their time? Maybe even let it run out to 0 while they're both still alive, creating a draw? Come on....

Situation 1v1 - referee might increase time, if is it needed to make a duel?

Yep,we are talking about when player/players from reg X run away from fight

[Pilophas]

Could you explain how 14players should not be able to run after other 14players without ever getting in touch with them?
I've never seen a situation like that and also it is not possible because the teams which is chasing the other one can always form a very widespread formation and with that deny any chance to run away for the other team...

Also imagine a 1vs8, a 2vs4, there are NO constellations that make it possible to precisely say which team should hurry up or not...

[Zahari]

Could you explain how 14players should not be able to run after other 14players without ever getting in touch with them?
I've never seen a situation like that and also it is not possible because the teams which is chasing the other one can always form a very widespread formation and with that deny any chance to run away for the other team...

Also imagine a 1vs8, a 2vs4, there are NO constellations that make it possible to precisely say which team should hurry up or not...

It is possible when cuirassiers play against hussars (and im not talking about 14 vs 14)

[DarkLight]

Why all the fuzz? Admins should be the ones who decides when one team is delaying and when its not, its part of their job, the time limit rule its not necessary.

[Zahari]

Why all the fuzz? Admins should be the ones who decides when one team is delaying and when its not, its part of their job, the time limit rule its not necessary.

It should be good too