North American Community Lists - NaCl [UPDATE 1.1: "Show Some Melee Competence"]

[BabyJesus]

List is pretty shit. It doesn't have me and Bill at tier 11

Bill and I need our special tier

[Stroke0fd34th]

Spoiler

Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.

(Still adding names and editing list)

Best NA Meleers of All Times:

Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)

Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)

Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)

Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Maple (3eVolt)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | DJOverJoy (5th)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)

I'd disagree with a lot of whats on there. A handful of people should be rotated around and some added, but you quit playing NW for a while, so you seem to favor the "older" players rather than newer ones. I joined the community mid 2014, and really only became a good player sometime 2015, so i can't really evaluate a lot of the older players. List is 5/7.

[close]

98e/Nr48KH was when I was at muh best not 4th, list has no credibility, get rekt kid.

[Mexican]

Spoiler

Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.

(Still adding names and editing list)

Best NA Meleers of All Times:

Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)

Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)

Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)

Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Maple (3eVolt)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | DJOverJoy (5th)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)

[close]

thanks 4 boosting my ego ritz, but yeah i would agree there are some newer players that are good rn but since the community has started to decline in the last year or so nobody has really taken notice of them.

also i was never 12th, i was probably in my prime when i was with the 71st or a bit before

[Stroke0fd34th]

Spoiler

Spoiler

Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.

(Still adding names and editing list)

Best NA Meleers of All Times:

Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)

Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)

Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)

Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Maple (3eVolt)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | DJOverJoy (5th)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)

[close]

thanks 4 boosting my ego ritz, but yeah i would agree there are some newer players that are good rn but since the community has started to decline in the last year or so nobody has really taken notice of them.

also i was never 12th, i was probably in my prime when i was with the 71st or a bit before

[close]

Nah, anyone who hasn't been playing since 2012 needs to uninstall.

[Rutger Müller]

Also in regards to andeefancyregs
Fancy is a really under rated in game leader probably a mid 80 in my opinion

if he is a mid 80 i must be a 90

[MackCW]

Only took 9 pages for people to get their e-peen hurt. Actually not bad...

[Rutger Müller]

I laughed when I saw "Gruoupfighting Tourney" performace on there to find myself 2nd to last  .

I agree Alex should be higher lol

No offense, but some of you guys weren't around in 2012-13, especially when melee was faster. There are a lot of guys on that list that you aren't familiar with who are still easily better than those that came later.

Most of the guys who've been in the community that long would agree.

true but there's also guys who have come along later that have become good for their time as well. Also, some of the older guys definitely aren't as good as they used to be

[Jarl Ballin Swag]

Spoiler

Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.

(Still adding names and editing list)

Best NA Meleers of All Times:

Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)

Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)

Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)

Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Maple (3eVolt)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | DJOverJoy (5th)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)

I'd disagree with a lot of whats on there. A handful of people should be rotated around and some added, but you quit playing NW for a while, so you seem to favor the "older" players rather than newer ones. I joined the community mid 2014, and really only became a good player sometime 2015, so i can't really evaluate a lot of the older players. List is 5/7.

[close]

Since coming back I haven't noticed anyone that really was that overpowering that is not already on the list. Unless someone got good December 2014 and stopped playing recently that the others that made the list and I don't know about then please share.

[Theodin]

Spoiler

Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.

(Still adding names and editing list)

Best NA Meleers of All Times:

Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)

Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)

Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)

Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Maple (3eVolt)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | DJOverJoy (5th)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)

I'd disagree with a lot of whats on there. A handful of people should be rotated around and some added, but you quit playing NW for a while, so you seem to favor the "older" players rather than newer ones. I joined the community mid 2014, and really only became a good player sometime 2015, so i can't really evaluate a lot of the older players. List is 5/7.

[close]

Since coming back I haven't noticed anyone that really was that overpowering that is not already on the list. Unless someone got good December 2014 and stopped playing recently that the others that made the list and I don't know about then please share.

Once again, have Apoc and Maple update your list with 2015 guys. No offense Ritz but you weren't very good after December 2014, and there are a few guys who came after you that were good.

[Jarl Ballin Swag]

Spoiler

Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.

(Still adding names and editing list)

Best NA Meleers of All Times:

Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)

Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)

Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)

Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Maple (3eVolt)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | DJOverJoy (5th)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)

I'd disagree with a lot of whats on there. A handful of people should be rotated around and some added, but you quit playing NW for a while, so you seem to favor the "older" players rather than newer ones. I joined the community mid 2014, and really only became a good player sometime 2015, so i can't really evaluate a lot of the older players. List is 5/7.

[close]

Since coming back I haven't noticed anyone that really was that overpowering that is not already on the list. Unless someone got good December 2014 and stopped playing recently that the others that made the list and I don't know about then please share.

Once again, have Apoc and Maple update your list with 2015 guys. No offense Ritz but you weren't very good after December 2014, and there are a few guys who came after you that were good.

Apoc helped me make the list.

[Theodin]

Spoiler

Spoiler

Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.

(Still adding names and editing list)

Best NA Meleers of All Times:

Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)

Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)

Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)

Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Maple (3eVolt)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | DJOverJoy (5th)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)

I'd disagree with a lot of whats on there. A handful of people should be rotated around and some added, but you quit playing NW for a while, so you seem to favor the "older" players rather than newer ones. I joined the community mid 2014, and really only became a good player sometime 2015, so i can't really evaluate a lot of the older players. List is 5/7.

[close]

Since coming back I haven't noticed anyone that really was that overpowering that is not already on the list. Unless someone got good December 2014 and stopped playing recently that the others that made the list and I don't know about then please share.

Once again, have Apoc and Maple update your list with 2015 guys. No offense Ritz but you weren't very good after December 2014, and there are a few guys who came after you that were good.

[close]

Apoc helped me make the list.

Then Apoc is a fuckin memer mate.

[ibsocal]

This list is racist against swordsmen! #officerlivesmatter

[Jarl Ballin Swag]

This list is racist against swordsmen! #officerlivesmatter

Not really, I prefer swords over bayonets as well. As I stated, I take into account how the players performed in 1v1 LB's as well. If the player performed well in 1v1's as officer I don't discount them.

[ibsocal]

Nope, you cant fool me RACIST! but it is missing a lot of the actual people who should be well known for swordsmanship and looks a lot more like a best bayonet list rather than a best melee of all time list.

PLG and 1LH probably have the most active swordsmen in the NA Community(LIR have a few also) and have been having weekly tournaments for mounted as well as dismounted sword fighting championships for ever, so at least between us two regiments(+the few others regs we let in) we know who the better sword fighters are but I don't think the community really cares about us swordsmen a whole lot enough to implement them into any lists though ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[Orcaryo]

King Bill isn't on that list, bad list