VonBergen you are clearly a very trusting person and the Nr4 is one of my favourite regiments (I especially love Beatz
) but you have too much faith in people. To assume that nothing should be done and people should just stop breaking the rules has not, and will never, work.
The ID list is a good idea, albeit, a lot of work for Rommel and co. but if they have the patience then it could be great. However, I'm not sure it is worth it for Rommel. Having to deal with all the, for lack of better term, 'salt' is a time consuming and boring process that I became familiar with after running the Groupfighting Server for while and it begins to really make you lose faith in people.
Having said that, the people that have been accused of playing for two regiments really don't seem to make that much of a difference. The regiment more capable in groupfighting always wins anyway.