Nice update. It's quite funny reading some of the comments, not sure if people are trolling?
The first part is a rating for all time and they've split the list's in to different eras to give a perspective of longevity and skill over time so you can argue about who is the best at peak from which era all you want, overall very fair ratings.
If you were purely basing it on stats Extazz is the greatest player of all-time given he has been consistently a top player for 6-7 years purely because he has been playing for that damn long and still remaining relevant.
It's a shame EGS began with a depreciated competition, and now is arguably the weakest I've ever seen (staining the achievements of a post lock down place), but you can't deny the list is about as good as you will get for an all-time.