Gibby & Herishey's All Time NW List(s) - Final Update Posted!

[Herishey]

Herishey tier 1 all time??? but never in tier one in any era???!!!

I am tier 1 in an era. Nice try at the baits again Vegitable.

and marquez is tier 1 in 2 different eras and tier 2 in other eras and hes tier 2 of all time kinda sus ngl heri kinda sus

If Marquez was 11-20 we had agreed to move him up but as it came out after all the feedback he went into 21-30 which meant with all his eras combined he didn't quite make it yet, maybe in the next one. He's not the only player top 10 in 2 eras but some of the others are in the shorter eras which is why they're not tier 1.

[Golden.]

My only question is why DOMI T1 but not Elsse?

[Herishey]

My only question is why DOMI T1 but not Elsse?

DOMI is in an extra era.

[Golden.]

My only question is why DOMI T1 but not Elsse?

DOMI is in an extra era.

Going off that logic you've got  Evanovic in only 2  top 10 eras too. I understand the 'stature' of the era and etc but it does seem a little arbitrary at that point, I understand there's always flaws in the list and the difficulty of an all-time. From my perspective DOMI, Elsse and Shadey were some of last greatest players i've seen in the game, given that Elsse and Domi both have pretty similar tournament statistics (off my head) it seems a little odd to place entirely in different tiers. (Especially with Shadey sat in T2 and his achievements in PB).

I would have placed DOMI, Elsse and Shadey T1 or left them all out not one above the other two considering the differences between those three is extremely minimal all-time.

Other changes were good so good job 

[Herishey]

My only question is why DOMI T1 but not Elsse?

DOMI is in an extra era.

Going off that logic you've got  Evanovic in only 2  top 10 eras too. I understand the 'stature' of the era and etc but it does seem a little arbitrary at that point, I understand there's always flaws in the list and the difficulty of an all-time. From my perspective DOMI, Elsse and Shadey were some of last greatest players i've seen in the game, given that Elsse and Domi both have pretty similar tournament statistics (off my head) it seems a little odd to place entirely in different tiers. (Especially with Shadey sat in T2 and his achievements in PB).

I would have placed DOMI, Elsse and Shadey T1 or left them all out not one above the other two considering the differences between those three is extremely minimal all-time.

Other changes were good so good job 

Both Shadey and Elsse had one less than DOMI hence my decision. But if they get into another era ofc they will go up.

[Gibby Jr]

My only question is why DOMI T1 but not Elsse?

DOMI is in an extra era.

Going off that logic you've got  Evanovic in only 2  top 10 eras too. I understand the 'stature' of the era and etc but it does seem a little arbitrary at that point, I understand there's always flaws in the list and the difficulty of an all-time. From my perspective DOMI, Elsse and Shadey were some of last greatest players i've seen in the game, given that Elsse and Domi both have pretty similar tournament statistics (off my head) it seems a little odd to place entirely in different tiers. (Especially with Shadey sat in T2 and his achievements in PB).

I would have placed DOMI, Elsse and Shadey T1 or left them all out not one above the other two considering the differences between those three is extremely minimal all-time.

Other changes were good so good job 

The length of the eras is important to take into consideration as well. DOMI appears in the top 10 in 3 eras, but these are the shortest eras - they total at 2 years from start to finish, and DOMI's entry into the top 10 only happened in the latter half of the "Remnants" era, so really it's more like a year and a half. Evanovic is top 10 in the two longest eras, totaling at just over three years from start to finish, and is then in the top 11-20 in the subsequent "Twin Titans" era, giving him a very long total time as a top player. DOMI is only really edged into a tier 1 all time because he's also in the top 11-20 in the "Late New Gen" era. If performances remain consistent, and I see no reason why they wouldn't, I imagine Elsse, Shadey and Marquez will all end up in tier 1 all time after the next era.

[LeBrave]

Why isnt lebrave in tier 1?

If that's a serious question in the last era since I updated it he only made one more top 30. Normally you need at least 2 top 10's in two of the longer era's though it depends which ones are seen as more significant.

Im behind so many retard in the actuel list or old top30 that running around the arena 10 times when they are in front of me is probably a skill factor that makes them in front of me in the list.

[Shadey]

Justice for LeBrave 🇫🇷

[Dan the Seagull Chef]

Frisbee?

[Herishey]

Dream teams also now updated which concludes this update for the all time list;

Nation Dream Teams-

IRE - ONeil for USE
GRE - Kostas for Rommel, Ntinos for blee
BE - Barro for Cedric
PORT - Pinto for Allisser, Salgado for MikeHawk, Rodrigues for Titolas, Cortez for PrePre add R1baz cpt
SCO - Jerome for Fungus
UKR - Tw1ster for Stex
TR - Ironreign for Toi, Strawhead for Gatts, Sanel for Aurius
RUS - Severus for Shaker
FRA - Elsse in for Dren, Zeyden for Spacekiller
GER - Bunter for NIFU

I don't think I missed anyone but this part can be hard especially for smaller nations.

[AccursedGull]

How dare you to remove spacekiller

[Nock]

imagine putting in elsse and not legend nock ? hello ? elsse in my pocket everyday of the week (not weekends though)

[Steinmann]

Justice for LeBrave 🇫🇷

[Elsse]

imagine putting in elsse and not legend nock ? hello ? elsse in my pocket everyday of the week (not weekends though)

The only answer I can provide is:

Spoiler [close]

[Nock]

imagine putting in elsse and not legend nock ? hello ? elsse in my pocket everyday of the week (not weekends though)

The only answer I can provide is:

Spoiler [close]

Spoiler

Merci pour ça monsieur

[close]