Gibby & Herishey's All Time NW List(s) - Final Update Posted!

[Gibby Jr]

[Rikkert]

[sirkaide]

Spoiler

It really seems like you are having a hard-time following your own narrative. It just so happens it's a trait noticeable with many people so caught-up in their own lies, they can no longer distinguish the truth from the rest.

You claimed the RGL as a competition was flawed and backed-up your argument by giving the example of three 'finals' you invited for. According to your story, that means that three regiments took the risk of cheating to get you in their ranks for an important match / a final. Which goes back to my point: I can eventually understand it (with great difficulty) for Hursty and Hypno but I don't find reasonable to believe anyone would cheat to have you play an important melee-focused final. Let alone three times. That just doesn't really make any sense to me and that's the sole justification for pointing out your actual individual melee level at the time.

Let's not hide what this is really about Kaide. You always had a massive victim syndrome with the 59th, you always considered your regiment (you been claiming it many times to anyone who would want to hear it) to be one of the best competitive of all time. Now that people made extensive researches showing that, despite the 59th having been one of the largest lasting community on the game, your achievements in competitive grounds are nothing particularly amazing, you suddenly re-appear and try to diminish the achievements of others in order to get yours to be praised and throw the most obvious bullshit on this thread in a piss-poor attempt to get your point across. That's why I am so vocal (aggressive) about it and that's why I have always found your narsissic and delusional personality impossible to cope with.

With that being said, and for what it's worth, I was part of the 85e (even lead it for a little while) which is ranked 12th on this 'All-Time' list and if you were to ask me what structure had a larger impact on NW between the 85e and the 59th, I wouldn't even dare to compare myself to the community you created, simply because there is a world between the two. The competitive achievements we (85e) got were only meant to make our regiment look good and didn't improve the NW community whatsoever whereas the 59th, through many things (events, servers and whatnot) eventually contributed in a much more beneficial way to making the NW community active, thrilling and unique.

I am certain that if the community wasn't so focused on highlighting competitive results as the ultimate way to figure out the impact of a regiment in a given period of time, you wouldn't feel the need to constantly defend the 59th the way you do. But alas that's where we are left at and I know that I can write dozen of paragraphs about it, it's unlikely to change your opinion even in the slightest so I will leave it at that.


Also cut off the IRL attacks right here, right now. That's petty and below the two of you.

[close]

Sorry Tardet but I can't be arsed reading your paragraph. I think your a good bloke and nice guy. I just wanted to ask hersh a few questions, as I believe the 59th should have been included in the 2019 section, and it makes sense to have a competitive ranking which excludes the 59th (not).

[Vegi.]

I don't like reading books on some video game forum, but this one was worth to read.

[Tardet]

Spoiler

Spoiler

It really seems like you are having a hard-time following your own narrative. It just so happens it's a trait noticeable with many people so caught-up in their own lies, they can no longer distinguish the truth from the rest.

You claimed the RGL as a competition was flawed and backed-up your argument by giving the example of three 'finals' you invited for. According to your story, that means that three regiments took the risk of cheating to get you in their ranks for an important match / a final. Which goes back to my point: I can eventually understand it (with great difficulty) for Hursty and Hypno but I don't find reasonable to believe anyone would cheat to have you play an important melee-focused final. Let alone three times. That just doesn't really make any sense to me and that's the sole justification for pointing out your actual individual melee level at the time.

Let's not hide what this is really about Kaide. You always had a massive victim syndrome with the 59th, you always considered your regiment (you been claiming it many times to anyone who would want to hear it) to be one of the best competitive of all time. Now that people made extensive researches showing that, despite the 59th having been one of the largest lasting community on the game, your achievements in competitive grounds are nothing particularly amazing, you suddenly re-appear and try to diminish the achievements of others in order to get yours to be praised and throw the most obvious bullshit on this thread in a piss-poor attempt to get your point across. That's why I am so vocal (aggressive) about it and that's why I have always found your narsissic and delusional personality impossible to cope with.

With that being said, and for what it's worth, I was part of the 85e (even lead it for a little while) which is ranked 12th on this 'All-Time' list and if you were to ask me what structure had a larger impact on NW between the 85e and the 59th, I wouldn't even dare to compare myself to the community you created, simply because there is a world between the two. The competitive achievements we (85e) got were only meant to make our regiment look good and didn't improve the NW community whatsoever whereas the 59th, through many things (events, servers and whatnot) eventually contributed in a much more beneficial way to making the NW community active, thrilling and unique.

I am certain that if the community wasn't so focused on highlighting competitive results as the ultimate way to figure out the impact of a regiment in a given period of time, you wouldn't feel the need to constantly defend the 59th the way you do. But alas that's where we are left at and I know that I can write dozen of paragraphs about it, it's unlikely to change your opinion even in the slightest so I will leave it at that.


Also cut off the IRL attacks right here, right now. That's petty and below the two of you.

[close]

Sorry Tardet but I can't be arsed reading your paragraph. I think your a good bloke and nice guy. I just wanted to ask hersh a few questions, as I believe the 59th should have been included in the 2019 section, and it makes sense to have a competitive ranking which excludes the 59th.

[close]

Fair. I never minded the questions, just what followed them and which in my eyes, was unnecessary to begin with.

[Rikkert]

Ok so before anyone gets their tits into more of a tangle.

Herishey and I spoke about adding a list of regiments (not in any particular order) to give a shoutout to certain regiments for their efforts towards growing and improving the community. This will probs be added at some point as it requires no extra research into anything.

As I sadly expected, we probably should've released this "shout-out list" at the same time as the main competitive list as it definitely would've prevented some of this shit.

That being said it was lovely to have some proper salt on fse again, thanks for coming.

Edit: I will probably release the spreadsheet with all the information on it soon as that would be much easier than replying to every single message separately on here.

[maskmanmarks]

Ok so before anyone gets their tits into more of a tangle.

Herishey and I spoke about adding a list of regiments (not in any particular order) to give a shoutout to certain regiments for their efforts towards growing and improving the community. This will probs be added at some point as it requires no extra research into anything.

As I sadly expected, we probably should've released this "shout-out list" at the same time as the main competitive list as it definitely would've prevented some of this shit.

That being said it was lovely to have some proper salt on fse again, thanks for coming.

Edit: I will probably release the spreadsheet with all the information on it soon as that would be much easier than replying to every single message separately on here.

is that it for tonight then? Shows over?!?

[sirkaide]

Ok so before anyone gets their tits into more of a tangle.

Herishey and I spoke about adding a list of regiments (not in any particular order) to give a shoutout to certain regiments for their efforts towards growing and improving the community. This will probs be added at some point as it requires no extra research into anything.

As I sadly expected, we probably should've released this "shout-out list" at the same time as the main competitive list as it definitely would've prevented some of this shit.

That being said it was lovely to have some proper salt on fse again, thanks for coming.

Edit: I will probably release the spreadsheet with all the information on it soon as that would be much easier than replying to every single message separately on here.

You certainly encouraged the salt. I made a few points that the 59th should have been included in the 2019 tier.  Which is not unreasonable considering we beat and drew with 3 of the teams on the 2019 list in the EIC. And certain people felt the need to post. I know I attract the shit posters but Jesus, I was only really interested in what Hersh had to say. Consdiering he drafted this thread. I've never once claimed the 59th was the greatest regiment or the anywhere near the top tier.  I am perhaps the only person to have led a regiment against every single regiment mentioned in this entire thread. I know more then most on what makes these regiments great and how they played. I fought all the greats and their regiments Tavington, Stefan, Karth, Donald, Price, Matty, GI etc. I know our place, and its not the top, but I do think we should have been put on the 2019 list, but I understand the formula.

[Herishey]

Ok so before anyone gets their tits into more of a tangle.

Herishey and I spoke about adding a list of regiments (not in any particular order) to give a shoutout to certain regiments for their efforts towards growing and improving the community. This will probs be added at some point as it requires no extra research into anything.

As I sadly expected, we probably should've released this "shout-out list" at the same time as the main competitive list as it definitely would've prevented some of this shit.

That being said it was lovely to have some proper salt on fse again, thanks for coming.

Edit: I will probably release the spreadsheet with all the information on it soon as that would be much easier than replying to every single message separately on here.

You certainly encouraged the salt. I made a few points that the 59th should have been included in the 2019 tier.  Which is not unreasonable considering we beat and drew with 3 of the teams on the 2019 list in the EIC. And certain people felt the need to post. I know I attract the shit posters but Jesus, I was only really interested in what Hersh had to say. I've never once claimed the 59th was the greatest regiment or the anywhere near the top tier.  I am perhaps the only person to have led a regiment against every single regiment mentioned in this entire thread. I know more then most on what makes these regiments great and how they played. I fought all the greats and their regiments Tavington, Stefan, Karth, Donald, Price, Matty, GI etc. I know our place, and its not the top, but I do think we should have been put on the 2019 list, but I understand the formula.

I don't tend to argue on FSE anymore, if you want a response from me best to ask on Steam bud.

But aside from the provoking Rikkert is correct in how we did it.  As rikkert said a hall of fame may be coming soon.

[DarkTemplar]

some kind words

honestly, thank you for the work

of course I would change some ratings here and there (especially for 72nd of course  ) but I think you tried your best to give it as much quality as possible, especially because u tried to focus on tournament achievements, not mainly on your feelings .
This work was not asked by anyone, but you did it to preserve some highlights of the 8 years of NW, which is simply awesome
I'm looking forward to the spreadsheet from rikkert, and to honourable mentions for tournament hosts, community suppliers etc

[Elsse]

Melsyo fapping on Tardets post

[Kore]

Nice

[Golden.]

You would need to make a casual list with 1st prawns preobraz and etc I think 59th could snugly fit on there.

 And if were talking impact to the community it doesnt even compare to 63e 33rd etc lmao. Was slapping 59th up with wolpi chris zappy and 63e tim back in 2016 garbo reg.

[Tigere]

You would need to make a casual list with 1st prawns preobraz and etc I think 59th could snugly fit on there.

 And if were talking impact to the community it doesnt even compare to 63e 33rd etc lmao. Was slapping 59th up with wolpi chris zappy and 63e tim back in 2016 garbo reg.

Albert steinein

[HughHefner]

assuming it was a typo, you meant 17e (hughhefner) not pieter, right?