Spoiler
Amit I brought up Season 5 as a example because of the fact that there hasn't been justice for it. I said they had similar evidence with people admitting they did it, others accounting for it with their stories & one video to prove it. I only brought up the S5 incident because of how similar they were from how I saw it & thought if they both are getting banned then 91st should be punished aswell. I believe Oatmeal shouldn't of got punished that bad (3-5 game suspension) for tking when it was the 91st's fault for not accounting for every member to make sure that they were 91st players. If 91st actually checked each member before the match to make sure every member was theirs then the whole Oatmeal & MATT thing wouldn't of happened in the first place. Sure what they both did was wrong and they both should be punished. However, part of the blame must be on the 91st Officer Core for not doing a good job for accounting for their members which is like I wish their punishments was shortened. Of course it is going to be hard to convince people that the "rumors" were true since it happens 3 seasons ago. When it was rumors after that match was over none of the mods bother to check the server logs at the time to confirm if it was true or not (Not sure why they didn't). Of course Bean didn't want to make the call S6 because it would seem bias but I hope Russian would actually want to try and do one more investigation on it. I can still play NWL Amit & not accept the 91st winning S5.
The only people that would have the actual right (though not really) to change that outcome are the three that moderated
that season. I can't speak for Windflower but at that time Cheesey didn't give me access to the logs for the NANWL server and even then I don't remember hearing of these rumors until a couple of weeks after
I've talked with Amit before and he's right, though there are screenshots of players there's nothing solid like a screenshot of the teamspeak and never will be. 91st won that league no matter who does or doesn't like it. And even if you try to use this past Incident as ammunition for the Matt and Oatmeal ordeal, There are several differences We didn't know we were playing them as we just stopped using historical names and they already had tags on the teamspeak giving us no reason to question them, (Which is partly our fault I admit) Second noticeable difference there were actual logs of this Incident and we had GUIDs to go from and more proof to work from, as I stated earlier I had no access to NANWL server logs though that could've changed at just asking Cheesey, however I saw no reason to have them at that point as the season was already over.
There's more proof to go off of this situation and going back to S5 drama isn't going to change the current outcomes
However, placing the whole blame on an officer corp is Idiotic unless they knew who the smurfs actually were during the match. Sure, 91st officer corp wasn't completely blameless but it's the job of the Referees to ensure the people are playing are actual members no matter what time they came into the match.
Show Posts
