I would prefer if we could actually wait for Bravescot to come back. He can take all the time he needs and we can continue together with him later.I respect B-Scots leave time, and I appreciate his effort for us. However, we do not know when he would come back. It could take weeks and months.
I would prefer if we could actually wait for Bravescot to come back. He can take all the time he needs and we can continue together with him later.
Thanks for the idea, added a poll.I would prefer if we could actually wait for Bravescot to come back. He can take all the time he needs and we can continue together with him later.
How long will he be gone? We don't know yet.
I am thinking German unification.
Why didn't Volk give the notes?I don't know, she was acting blunt.
Was going to finally make the Civil war mod where every player could pick a state. But the thread was deleted(?) and all the works and maps i rounded up gone too. Anyways looking forward to the new bop nonethelessLooking forward to it too!
Man its sad noone chose LoTR.. i choose GoT than! A civil war forum game.. that ACTUALLY takes off would be nice though. Hmm.. so who is hosting?I am, of course.
Was going to finally make the Civil war mod where every player could pick a state. But the thread was deleted(?) and all the works and maps i rounded up gone too. Anyways looking forward to the new bop nonethelessi think duuring might be able to get it back for you if you ask him
If we did a GoT BoP. , would people play as the minor houses too?Yes, of course. If there are enough players, that is.
Lord of the Rings! But do you know what's even better than LotR BoP? Silmarillion BoP! Silmarillion after Nirnaeth Arnoediad when everyone started to fight against everyone else. Do it and I'll pay you with my virginity!I do not know Silmarillion that well sadly. I meant LotR universe.
Game is thrones is retaredes.No you
Got is actually going to be quite fun imoikr #StarkBias
Well I probably* won't be playing in a GoT BoP then. I don't want to be a great house and have people playing below meI understand, but as I mentioned beforehand - only if there are enough players, and you'd need to fill all the spots of the big houses of Westeros and the free cities + the Targariyan usurper.
Could i play horseno
Could i play horseno
go away kid
play cod or sumthin
Help, I dunno anything else about GoT other than it has incest.
I'll play if you let me and Otto have incest sex in gameThat's the sweetest thing anyone has ever said to me <3
Am I seeing things? Yesterday there were 2 votes for German unification and now there is only 1.I made it so people could change their votes if they want to. Someone changed his/her vote.
To be quite honest, I do not know how I will do a Game of Thrones one. It is too much work and I have a really short attention span. There are too many things to consider in a fictional world.
What do you say then, do ANOTHER vote to see what people prefer out of certain historical eras, keep the Game of Thrones idea, and actually let me start working on Iropia, if the team of Iropia would allow it?
Quite short for hosting such a complex game and making completely new mechanics. It could be a lot easier if we just do a 'normal' BoP.To be quite honest, I do not know how I will do a Game of Thrones one. It is too much work and I have a really short attention span. There are too many things to consider in a fictional world.
What do you say then, do ANOTHER vote to see what people prefer out of certain historical eras, keep the Game of Thrones idea, and actually let me start working on Iropia, if the team of Iropia would allow it?
Are you really sure you want to host a bop if your attention span is quite short? :-X
No matter what era you choose you are gonna have to make new mechanics
Which I do with both, the problem is the are a lot of "magic" mechanics that need to be implemented, which can be really hard and really op in the right hands.No matter what era you choose you are gonna have to make new mechanics
Game of Thrones is just a lot harder to run. More mechanisms to create. You can easily read up on the German unification or Colonialism in the 1770's, but to understand the Game of Thrones you either need to read the books or watch the series.
I can help with the German Unification, if needed. I know a thing or two. :-)
Aftermath of WW2 (Cold War, etc)
Agreed.Aftermath of WW2 (Cold War, etc)
That would be interesting.
you can easily read up about game of thrones too. I know next to nothing about the German unification so I would have to look up an entire era. That's not exactly easy. And frankly I find that era uninteresting.No matter what era you choose you are gonna have to make new mechanics
Game of Thrones is just a lot harder to run. More mechanisms to create. You can easily read up on the German unification or Colonialism in the 1770's, but to understand the Game of Thrones you either need to read the books or watch the series.
Any chance for era in which people still used to bash each other with sharp pieces of metal? Antiquity, medieval, Renaissance? There already are other modern BoPs.Can do. Age of Enlightenment , anyone?
Y no German Unification?
Spring of Nations is German Unification.Y no German Unification?
Why only one vote for user?No reason, really.
Didn't mclovin try a rise of the Roman empires bop? And didn't it fail miserably?He actually did the fall of the Roman Empire. Yes, it failed. It was because 1914 was blooming at the time.
i think one of the problems no one knew what to do. Like no one knew proper army sizes or how the economy workedDidn't mclovin try a rise of the Roman empires bop? And didn't it fail miserably?He actually did the fall of the Roman Empire. Yes, it failed. It was because 1914 was blooming at the time.
That was exactly the problem, McLovin expected people to do historical research when they didn't. People need to be fed with information, other wise nothing goes well. I will make sure people know their approximate sizes.i think one of the problems no one knew what to do. Like no one knew proper army sizes or how the economy workedDidn't mclovin try a rise of the Roman empires bop? And didn't it fail miserably?He actually did the fall of the Roman Empire. Yes, it failed. It was because 1914 was blooming at the time.
That was exactly the problem, McLovin expected people to do historical research when they didn't. People need to be fed with information, other wise nothing goes well. I will make sure people know their approximate sizes.i think one of the problems no one knew what to do. Like no one knew proper army sizes or how the economy workedDidn't mclovin try a rise of the Roman empires bop? And didn't it fail miserably?He actually did the fall of the Roman Empire. Yes, it failed. It was because 1914 was blooming at the time.
Even 1774, I think we need a big head start.That was exactly the problem, McLovin expected people to do historical research when they didn't. People need to be fed with information, other wise nothing goes well. I will make sure people know their approximate sizes.i think one of the problems no one knew what to do. Like no one knew proper army sizes or how the economy workedDidn't mclovin try a rise of the Roman empires bop? And didn't it fail miserably?He actually did the fall of the Roman Empire. Yes, it failed. It was because 1914 was blooming at the time.
Pretty much.
By the way, if you are starting in the year 1776, I advise actually starting in 1775. Maybes around January 1775, to give the players some time to prepare.
Y no German Unification?
Y no German Unification?
EDIT: I've also looked at your map, McLovin, and it's accurate in regard to the provinces. Of course the borders are way different, but they're also way too complicated to make the borders accurate.
Y no German Unification?
EDIT: I've also looked at your map, McLovin, and it's accurate in regard to the provinces. Of course the borders are way different, but they're also way too complicated to make the borders accurate.
Good to hear. By the way, German unification would fall under the spring of Nations.
Come on, roleplay! Creative design! Vote medieval! Do not be limited to the ways of Geneva, invent new weapons and armors that beat out your neighbors or just out-chivalry them, build a million gallows and hang your enemies all at once like the mad king you are! Come ooon!If Audiate came out of his hole to say his opinion here, I think you guys should listen to him. Love you Audi <3
CK2 > Your shitty HoI and Vicky and EU mentalities >:(
Would love a Seven Years War BoP. A German Unification BoP wouldn't include much action. Generally everyone just wants to unite, and then what lol? Medieval is too chaotic, imo.7 years war is pre-American Independence, so could do be an option.
The ideal thing with the Seven Years War is that everyone is at each other's throats. Imperialism, religion, dominance, influence, technology.Of course I would need a decision, and currently we have BoP 1776 leading. If we see until the 22nd that 1776 wins, then we'll do a vote between the 7 Years War, or American War of Independence.
Can someone that wants the 1776 BoP explain to me why? Britain and the U.S.? And some Indians? That's it?It's not just that, it's the surrounding world. France, Spain, Germany, Netherlands, more. Even though I know what you mean, it has limitations.
Wouldn't the Seven Years War cover more and open up for 1776 afterwards?Aye it would. It only makes sense. But let's just wait and see for now :D
Medieval is worst <.< >.>
rhen will probably just leave the game no matter what era you choose ::)Medieval is worst <.< >.>
rhen will probably just leave the game no matter what era you choose ::)Medieval is worst <.< >.>Spoiler<3[close]
If anyone leaves my game for any in-gane reasons, will bring destruction on his country, just saying.umm I don't think that's a good idea. I hope you are just doing a social experiment
I never said it shall be unplayable. I will actually make it as if the King for example was assasinated, and there's a bit less stability and etc.If anyone leaves my game for any in-gane reasons, will bring destruction on his country, just saying.umm I don't think that's a good idea. I hope you are just doing a social experiment
But seriously how will destroying the country and making it unplayable an effective way to punish someone who left the game?
I never said it shall be unplayable. I will actually make it as if the King for example was assasinated, and there's a bit less stability and etc.If anyone leaves my game for any in-gane reasons, will bring destruction on his country, just saying.umm I don't think that's a good idea. I hope you are just doing a social experiment
But seriously how will destroying the country and making it unplayable an effective way to punish someone who left the game?
That's just a challenge, if the replacing player is skilled enough he would be able to clutch out of the detriment process.I never said it shall be unplayable. I will actually make it as if the King for example was assasinated, and there's a bit less stability and etc.If anyone leaves my game for any in-gane reasons, will bring destruction on his country, just saying.umm I don't think that's a good idea. I hope you are just doing a social experiment
But seriously how will destroying the country and making it unplayable an effective way to punish someone who left the game?
Not a lot, just a bit less.
but that just makes it less likely for someone to actually want to play as that nation. And again how does that actually punish the person that left the game?I never said it shall be unplayable. I will actually make it as if the King for example was assasinated, and there's a bit less stability and etc.If anyone leaves my game for any in-gane reasons, will bring destruction on his country, just saying.umm I don't think that's a good idea. I hope you are just doing a social experiment
But seriously how will destroying the country and making it unplayable an effective way to punish someone who left the game?
Can't people accept RP? I don't think there was enough RP in the last games.but that just makes it less likely for someone to actually want to play as that nation. And again how does that actually punish the person that left the game?I never said it shall be unplayable. I will actually make it as if the King for example was assasinated, and there's a bit less stability and etc.If anyone leaves my game for any in-gane reasons, will bring destruction on his country, just saying.umm I don't think that's a good idea. I hope you are just doing a social experiment
But seriously how will destroying the country and making it unplayable an effective way to punish someone who left the game?
I think Age of Enlightenment 2.0.I was thinking that too, but I was thinking raw medieval times too would be a bit better.
I think Age of Enlightenment 2.0.
Every time this guy speaks he says gems, listen to him.I think Age of Enlightenment 2.0.
That would be nice only if we had more mods than last time and if the people behind it aren't going to say "alright, gg, it was fun" and close it when another BoP comes. I'm still waiting to this day for those Savoy provinces.
I think everyone should look through the start dates of CK2 and EU4, year by year, and suggest some good looking, unique, and flavored starts. It's cooler to have counts and dukes to start with so that players can form Kingdoms later, in my opinion, so I'd recommend the earlier start dates in both games.
But yeah, Age of Enlightenment 2 would be cool, it would just have to be balanced slightly and some research would have to be done to fairly determine who had what economy, wealth, influence, and power, as well as what were appropriate inventions for the time period, because I think some people were off by a little bit there. I would have liked to see a fair amount of knights running around still, just for a little while before they became totally useless. ::)
Can we Judt start a goddamn bop already?Yeah, it's settled on a medieval BoP. I was thinking about starting like in Medieval 2 with the aftermath of the battle of Hastings, but then I figured it might be a better idea to do a later date. Pre-age of enlightement kinda, so you guys could do the research of shit yourself.
I would say 100 year war time period. What do you all say?
How about we make it a HRE BoP only? Basically remove all lands surrounding it, making it one big island.
Here's a map I made like 2 years ago just because I was bored. Maybe it'll give you some inspiration.Spoiler(https://i.imgur.com/AFgcNYQ.png)[close]
Just an idea, btw.
And how many AI will this BoP not have?None of them?
Wouldn't the set period mean a shit load of nations and hence also AIs?Yes, but the AI will act inactive anyways like in mist games. Just when negotiated with or warred upon, there would be AI actions.
So do we have an exact year we're starting?Just the end of the 100 years war.
The end of it? If we take Fall of Constantinople as end of Middle Ages and Battle of Castillon as the end of Hundred Years' War, then our starting date wouldn't even be in the Middle Ages. I don't think that's what we all wanted when we voted for Medieval BoP. And I don't mean now that we should start few years earlier, but rather few tens or even hundreds years earlier. 12th or 13th century maybe? But that's just a suggestion, it's up to you to decide of course.
Well, the AI was active in AoE, it just responded to what else was happening. I remember some Electorates declaring some war when HRE was weakened to try to restrengthen it. AI in a BoP game should be the antibodies to what's happening in the game.True, actually. That's what I was thinking too.
The end of it? If we take Fall of Constantinople as end of Middle Ages and Battle of Castillon as the end of Hundred Years' War, then our starting date wouldn't even be in the Middle Ages. I don't think that's what we all wanted when we voted for Medieval BoP. And I don't mean now that we should start few years earlier, but rather few tens or even hundreds years earlier. 12th or 13th century maybe? But that's just a suggestion, it's up to you to decide of course.
To be fair, medieval was really vague. Perhaps we should open a new poll to specify the start dates. Something like:Do you really want to do another poll, though? I think best thing would be to just do the end of the Hundred Years War. It is still bashing people on the head with maces and slicing them with swords, but it is more elegant too and goes more towards the Age of Enlightenment.
- Early Medieval (400/500-900 AD) - Not really recommended though since it'll take a shit ton of research to get everything sorted, accurate, and yet balanced
- High Medieval (1000-1300 AD)
- Late Medieval (1300-1500 AD)
- Perhaps an AoE continuation option too
My guess is most people are thinking somewhere in the high medieval to late medieval ages, like 1200's-1500's. We should all also keep in mind that battles are decided based on attributing factors (like landscape/defending/attacking, weaponry, morale, experience, etc.) and dice rolls, and it's easier to roll for later weaponry like arquebuses and cannonry than it is to roll for sword swings and parries.
might as well (https://www.fsegames.eu/forum/index.php?topic=27198.0)I will slowly start building the mechanics over time.
lmao
Whatever it is, I'd be excited to see it started sooner rather than later.
Is there a new game starting anytime soon?If Nick is willing, sure. I found out I am busy all of July so a game could only start August time.
I feel like we're never going to have a forum game which will be active for more than 6 months.
Is there a new game starting anytime soon?If Nick is willing, sure. I found out I am busy all of July so a game could only start August time.
For a few months, then stop the game. Its pointlessIs there a new game starting anytime soon?If Nick is willing, sure. I found out I am busy all of July so a game could only start August time.
I am free after Friday for a few months so I'd be able to work on a Napoleonic one, the map will take a long time to complete however.
It would only be pointless if dazzer is allowed to play
I feel like a Game of thrones BoP would be good, starting just after the death of King Baratheon. Instead of playing as nations, we should play as characters, like playing as Renly or Ed.is that even a BoP? That sounds more like a roll to dodge
I feel like a Game of thrones BoP would be good, starting just after the death of King Baratheon. Instead of playing as nations, we should play as characters, like playing as Renly or Ed.is that even a BoP? That sounds more like a roll to dodge
It would only be pointless if dazzer is allowed to playyeah, I hope he wont be allowed to
It would only be pointless if dazzer is allowed to playyeah, I hope he wont be allowed to
I guess you wont be allowed either :/It would only be pointless if dazzer is allowed to playyeah, I hope he wont be allowed to
Now as it is settled that Dazzer mustn't play we should finally agree on the period.
It would only be pointless if dazzer is allowed to playyeah, I hope he wont be allowed to
Now as it is settled that Dazzer mustn't play we should finally agree on the period.
DONT BE CONFINED BY A POLLthe people wanted a medieval bop. You must give it to them
LIVE FREE
DONT BE CONFINED BY A POLLthe people wanted a medieval bop. You must give it to them
LIVE FREE
But there was a medieval BoP already. Why not something new?and there was 4 different ww1 games
DONT BE CONFINED BY A POLLthe people wanted a medieval bop. You must give it to them
LIVE FREE
democracy
pfft
DONT BE CONFINED BY A POLLthe people wanted a medieval bop. You must give it to them
LIVE FREE
democracy
pfft
Tbh we could do another poll with only two options (medieval & 1776) in order to get it verified. (I still think medieval is too big for a forumgame, far too many small states, I do not think it would work well)
just give me like a week and all those small states will be gone ;)DONT BE CONFINED BY A POLLthe people wanted a medieval bop. You must give it to them
LIVE FREE
democracy
pfft
Tbh we could do another poll with only two options (medieval & 1776) in order to get it verified. (I still think medieval is too big for a forumgame, far too many small states, I do not think it would work well)
Well the Enlightenment the Swiss did have an unlimited amount of money.
" I'm gonna build 100 new fortresses and find a mercenary army that is bigger than yours"
Forum games are dead. Thanks audiate
i guess soyou scared everyone when you brought up how op Switzerland was
no just you, coward, afraid of neutrality(https://www.fsegames.eu/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fforums.na.leagueoflegends.com%2Fboard%2Fattachment.php%3Fattachmentid%3D1047453%26amp%3Bd%3D1408087250&hash=be06c7de4f9b5b2e18df3a248c5450c517ecdac6)
Cats dont eat seagullsseagulls eat cats
Whatever happened to that Medieval BoP?Which one?
Medieval BoP - 12 (44.4%)We already sped way past this topic ???
Whatever happened to that Medieval BoP?warband never started hosting it