Here's my take (And the take of a few others) on the overall melee list, I don't mean to offend anyone. Note: If people are the same overall it means they are equally skilled. This list takes into account how well these players have performed in 1v1 LB's, group fighting tournaments, and dueling tournaments.
(Still adding names and editing list)
Best NA Meleers of All Times:
Elite Tier:
96 | Tammo (12th)
96 | Jackie Chan (12th,71st)
96 | Lithios (9y)
Tier 1:
94 | AsianP (3eVolt,79th)
94 | Havoc (2ndQF)
94 | RitZ (12th,3eVolt)
94 | Point Blank (9y)
93 | Coconut (12th)
91 | Breaches (12th)
Tier 2:
90 | Ghost (12th)
90 | Zzehth (12th,71st)
90 | AP0CALYPS3 (9y,3eVolt,12th)
90 | Colonys22 (7y,12th)
89 | SilentMan (Pub,63e)
88 | Zorkoth (12th)
88 | Tico (12th)
87 | Slick (9y)
87 | Vortex (15e)
87 | PolarBear (9y)
87 | Mathias (12th)
87 | Who- (12th)
87 | Scopes (9y)
87 | DarthJezus (9y)
87 | Botvinnik (7thRFG)
87 | Monty (12th,3eVolt)
87 | Maple (3eVolt)
86 | Psycho (MarinsGarde)
86 | Sleek (9y)
86 | PaperSalad (9y)
86 | Rere (15e,9y)
86 | Mang (Pub)
86 | Hellomoto (9y)
86 | Freddy Kruger (12th)
86 | Speirs (15e)
Tier 3:
85 | Saltyy (9y)
85 | Fireboy (1stRddt)
85 | Mexicant (12th)
85 | DragonPuff (63e,3eVolt)
85 | Puppytron (Pub, 58e)
85 | Godfried (4th)
85 | Pinoy (9y)
84 | ZachAttack (9y)
84 | Emocelestia (9y)
84 | Kovy (Pub,58e)
84 | Mack (9y)
84 | DJOverJoy (5th)
84 | Fallout (3eVolt,12th)
83 | Xeroth (3eVolt)
83 | Ramzey (9y)
83 | Smithy (MarinsGarde)
83 | Redrum (63e)
83 | Krittix (9y)
83 | Rafael (9y)
83 | Shine (9y)
82 | GLMan (9y)
82 | GameChanger (MarinsGrde)
82 | PsychoTwins (9y)
82 | RedWall (12th)
82 | Rogelio (9y)
82 | DrBYeBye (54th)
82 | MewMew (Pub)
81 | Alexander (5th)
80 | Millander (1stFKI)